Believing you know the truth is dangerous
Religious types often take great umbrage when their faith is compared to belief in fairies. In fact it is the fairy believers who ought to be offended. The evidence for fairies includes countless eyewitness testimonials and photographs as well as being part of an ancient folk tradition common across most of Europe.
The Christian belief that Jesus was born of a virgin and rose from the dead is supported by four conflicting, contradictory and non-eyewitness testimonies, two of which do not even mention the virgin birth. They are politically biased, textually dubious and almost always read in translation.
Furthermore, belief in fairies is roughly compatible with the worldview offered by current science. (Hold with me here…) The ‘fairy hypothesis’ basically posits a species of as-yet-undiscovered winged humanoids. While this is superlatively unlikely, no scientific theories would have to be rewritten if it was proved true.
‘Fairy magic’ could be a form of advanced technology. If they really come from ‘fairyland’, perhaps they are somehow capable of shifting between dimensions. Science will need to be added to, and in some areas may need to be changed (how are insect wings able to bear all that weight? What did they evolve from? Where do those sparkles come from?). But the scientific project will continue as it has done before, perhaps with the fairies’ help.
Religious hypotheses, on the other hand, are incompatible with science. If we actually have an immortal soul, which is the root of our moral sense and supposed tendency towards ‘sin’, most of neuroscience and evolutionary biology will have to be abandoned. If prayer really is effective, then the scientific sampling techniques (which it has so far eluded) do not appear to be.
Let’s bite the bullet here – if science has somehow failed to detect the single biggest fact about the universe, while in the meantime hypothesising about the building blocks of matter and origins of life, there is probably something wrong with science altogether.
The usual response at this point is to invoke ‘faith’. This word has a great many meanings, but as far as I can tell, religious believers normally use it to mean a condition which affords a statement the status of ‘knowledge’ on the basis of less-than-usual evidence.
This is extremely dangerous. There are far more potentially harmful beliefs than potentially helpful ones, and most religions contain a mixture of both.
The majority of the population at the minute has faith that it is in some way superior to the rest of humanity – whether religiously, racially or nationally – and this is the cause of all wars, and most suffering.
Tony Blair recently said ‘If you talk about faith, people look at you like you’re some kind of nut’. If only. In fact you’re allowed to run a country. The faith of Blair and Bush has led our troops into Iraq. Both of them would have endorsed DICCU’s current slogan: ‘Know Truth’. They believed that they did: that the voice in their head was God, rather than their own delusions. Osama Bin Laden thought he knew the truth as well. The ideology which crashed those planes was the product of faith, while the planes themselves were a product of science’s systematised doubt.
George Bush put it nicely: ‘You’re either for us or against us.’ Damn straight.
