Beauty is a curse — the story of Olivier Giroud
By Aron Lavis
The football universe is one of quick assumptions and tribal prejudice. Reputations are manufactured out of thin air, but often set in stone. One stereotypical attribute, and a player’s image is defined forever — regardless of accuracy.
After all, as football fans we are in the entertainment business. We look for heroes, villains, and jokers to bolster the narratives which pervade the game and help us rationalise the events which occur on the pitch.
Such narratives can transform some careers. Yet for others, the unrelenting ascription of narrative and stereotype can form a ceiling, limiting the respect that they deserve from the football community of fans, journalists, and former players alike.
For an enduring example of this phenomena, we need not look further than Olivier Giroud.
For Giroud, an attempt to forge a respected career in the English game became an uphill battle before he even stepped onto the pitch. The striker entered English football in 2012 after his transfer to Arsene Wenger’s Arsenal – a team with a reputation for playing beautiful football but plagued with the narrative of being too ‘soft’, ‘pretty’ and ‘weak’ for the English game.
Moreover, as our football community gazed upon him, Giroud became instantaneously bound to a stereotype befitting his new team. Giroud is a beautiful man, too beautiful for fans to ignore.
And, to add insult to injury, he’s French. Therefore, news of Giroud’s cultural heritage combined with the genetic mastery of his face and the footballing stereotypes which plagued his new team, left English football with no choice.
His good looks cast a spotlight on every mistake he made and caused a serial underestimation of his talent.
He was to be cast as a ‘pretty boy’ who can’t handle our league and must never garner respect or admiration. Giroud quickly became a humorous ‘meme’. His good looks cast a spotlight on every mistake he made and caused a serial underestimation of his talent.
Giroud’s beauty intimidates, whilst his Frenchness awakens nationalistic fire, thus it is understandable that the collective defence mechanism of disparaging narratives and underestimation was enacted. However, in the spirit of footballing justice, a revisionist approach to Giroud’s place in football must go ahead. For he is an exceptional player who has been cursed by his beauty.
The beginnings of a credible case can be made with a mere list of Giroud’s sporting achievements. During his career, he has won the World Cup, Champions League, Europa League, Ligue 1, Serie A and 4 FA Cups.
Further to this, Giroud presides over an astoundingly consistent goalscoring record. The striker has won the ‘Golden Boot’ in both the Europa League and Ligue 1, he is the second highest goal scorer of all time for the French National team with 47 goals — only five behind Thierry Henry in 1st place — and he has reached double figures for goals in each of his last 11 seasons.
Giroud is a proven winner and a proven goal scorer for every team in which he has played.
Furthermore, one can build on such compelling hard evidence with an analysis of Giroud’s playing style. The foundation of Giroud’s footballing persona is forged not with hollow beauty.
In fact, in a sense of vindicating irony, Giroud’s game is underpinned by the ugly side of football. His true superpowers are his Herculean strength and Napoleonic brutality. Giroud displays aerial superiority over almost any opponent, providing a physical platform upon which his team can lean in moments of high pressure.
The Frenchman has aged like a fine Beaujolais.
However, Giroud is not solely a battering ram used to break through defences, his deft touches and impeccable vision around the box make him one of the great facilitators of the modern game. The sophistication of technique in Giroud’s style is demonstrated through his involvement in some of the most beautiful goals ever scored.
For example, his assist in that Jack Wilshere goal against Norwich is worthy of any world-class attacking midfielder. Moreover, Giroud can prove a devastating and advanced finisher, his ‘scorpion kick’ goal vs Crystal Palace — which won him a coveted FIFA Puskás award — will forever live on in the memory.
Crucially, much like some of his more celebrated contemporaries — such as Robert Lewandowski — the Frenchman has aged like a fine Beaujolais. His statistics and his impact have only improved since he entered his 30s. With six goal involvements in only nine games for AC Milan so far this season, Giroud’s best days are not over.
Now, Olivier Giroud is not worthy of world-class status. However, he is certainly worthy of more respect than he currently receives. In the unforgiving environment of football culture, a player can very rarely shake the stereotypes and baseless narratives formed around them during the infancy of their career.
The story of Giroud as a victim of serial underestimation holds up a mirror to English football and the preconceived, yet widely held, ideas which define it. Giroud’s beauty blinded many, prohibiting them from recognising his true quality.
Forgive them Olivier, for they were blind, and they could not see.
Image: Biser Todorov via Flickr

