BBC Proms 2020: Mahler and Mozart
By Matthew Pearson
The virtual Proms performance on the 26th August 2020 witnessed a return to one of the most celebrated performances in Proms history, given on 10 September 1987 by the Vienna Philharmonic, and conducted by Leonard Bernstein. Featuring Mozart’s Clarinet Concerto (soloist: Peter Schmidl) and Mahler’s colossal Symphony No. 5, this was only the orchestra’s second appearance at the Proms and, somewhat surprisingly, Bernstein’s Proms debut – he died only three years later.
The night’s performance of Mozart’s Clarinet Concerto, composed in 1791 for Viennese clarinettist Anton Stadler, was given by Peter Schmidl, the Vienna Philharmonic’s principal clarinettist, whose father and grandfather, too, played for the orchestra. Schmidl played with only occasional embellishments, resulting in a refreshingly straightforward and unfussy performance which aptly captured the wit and elegance of the concerto’s outer movements. There were times where semiquaver passages felt slightly rushed, resulting in slight loss of coordination between soloist and orchestra, but this did not detract from an otherwise assured performance. The Concerto’s celebrated second movement was rather spacious and indulgent – which will not appeal to those who favour the more delicate, classical poise of several more recent recordings – but Schmidl’s beautifully even, silky tone and his tender pianissimo register nonetheless seemed perfect for this movement. Most impressive was Schmidl’s energetic and rather playful account of the Concerto’s final movement, bringing a very fine performance to its exuberant conclusion.
Following the interval, we were treated to one of the most famous performances in Proms history. Leonard Bernstein felt a great personal affinity with Mahler, and has long been associated with the composer’s Fifth Symphony – indeed, he was buried with a copy of the score over his heart. Whilst some might object to Bernstein’s ostensibly ‘overdone’ interpretations of Mahler, I would argue that, here, Bernstein did no more or less than adhere fastidiously to the minutiae of Mahler’s score – and there are many. The attention to detail was remarkable, resulting in a thoroughly exhilarating performance.
He was buried with a copy of the score over his heart.
Bernstein contended that Mahler’s music was essentially childlike, in that it expresses the very extremes of human emotion. His philosophy was evident from the outset: the desolate ‘Funeral March’ theme of the first movement, in particular, was weighty and ponderous, with every note, rest and pause given a great deal of space, whilst the agitated second movement was performed with a similarly exaggerated sense of emotional turmoil.
Bernstein adopted a slower tempo than is often heard for the following Scherzo – Mahler himself felt that this movement was frequently performed took quickly. Although the intonation of the solo horn was occasionally dubious, the orchestra was particularly successful in conveying the movement’s sense of dance, and in accentuating the contrast between moments of almost Mozartian elegance and moments of grotesque turbulence.
The tempo of the Adagietto, perhaps the most famous movement of any Mahler Symphony, was perfectly judged, being neither so fast as to diminish the movement’s expansive sense of serenity, nor so slow as to blur the movement’s overall shape. The ending of the Adagietto was utterly sublime – once again, the Vienna Philharmonic’s enormous dynamic range made for utterly breathtaking music-making.
Characteristically, Bernstein and the Vienna Philharmonic held nothing back in the Symphony’s jubilant final movement. Mahler’s intricate counterpoint was delivered with a thrilling sense of gradual expanse, with huge dynamic contrasts and punchy accents always at the fore. Concluding in a cacophonous, almost manic Presto, this most exceptionally thrilling performance of Mahler’s titanic Symphony No. 5 was rightly greeted with an enormous wave of applause, its place solidified amongst the finest performances of the work ever given.
Featured Image: Maximus McCabe-Abel
