BBC Proms 2020: Birtwistle, Cornysh, Holst & Lambe

By Jieyi Li

This recording of the fifth concert from the 2013 Proms Chamber Music series provided an interval of more intimate, locally sourced music between performances of gargantuan vocal works such as Wagner’s Die Walkure the night before and Monteverdi’s Vespers that following evening. Conducted by Nicholas Kok and performed by the BBC singers and musicians from the Nash Ensemble, the programme overall presented three generations of English music, cleverly weaving works from the Renaissance between works from the English folk song revival and finishing with what is currently the sound of British contemporary music.

This concert opened with a foray into more foreign sound worlds with Group 3 from Holst’s Choral Hymns from the Rig Veda, the text of which was taken from the sacred Hindi text, which Holst himself translated from Sanskrit. Scored for female voices and harp, the spotlight was placed on the female members of the BBC singers. The well-blended voices and carefully controlled dynamics made way for shimmering moments in the harmonies of Hymn to Vena and Hymn to the Travellers, although the soaring soprano lines of Hymn to the Dawn could have benefited from less vibrato to sound less forceful. Hymn to the Waters could have adopted a slightly faster tempo, as the broader, more majestically written phrases suffered from sounding sluggish, yet the lightness of the tone sung by the singers and their dance-like energy was able to preserve the song’s effervescence.

“The members from the BBC singers carefully and successfully navigated the different stylistic and characteristic demands of each work with great tightness as an ensemble.”

William Cornysh’s Ave Maria Mater Dei and Walter Lambe’s Stella caeli, both being motets from the Eton Choirbook, introduced the lower voices of the choir, and altogether, the choir gave controlled and assured performances of both pieces. Overall, the members from the BBC singers carefully and successfully navigated the different stylistic and characteristic demands of each work with great tightness as an ensemble. This was most commendably displayed in Imogen Holst’s piece ‘Hallo, my fancy, wither wilt thou go?’ where the myriad of modes and difficult melodic lines were managed with precision.

“Birtwistle introduces ‘The Moth Requiem‘ to the audience as a piece about disappearance: of extinct species of moths, of people in his life, and eventually of his own life.”

However, if there was a piece that was most likely to have been at the forefront of the audience’s conversation at the end of the concert, it was Birtwistle’s The Moth Requiem. Present in the audience for the UK premiere of his piece, scored for twelve female singers, alto flute and three harps, Birtwistle introduces it to the audience as a piece about disappearance: of extinct species of moths, of people in his life, and eventually of his own life. Birtwistle chooses not to present his reflection on loss with sentimentality but with anger.  The Latin text is set so disjointedly that all sense of the text is lost, and the audience hears only vocables, sometimes babbling, sometimes wailing. The immense difficulty of the voice parts was handled expertly by the choir, with each singer confidently handling the responsibility of individual voice parts. The flautist showed impressive tonal control, mellow at some points and powerful at others. The most fascinating moments being where the sound of the alto flute merged with the female voices so that it was indiscernible whether it was the flute or the voice that was producing sound. Although the anger permeated to the very end, with the flute playing intensely at its lowest register whilst the harps struck percussively at their strings, there was nonetheless an undeniable beauty to its sound. Placed at the end of the programme, the wonder of female voices singing to lofty heights, coupled with the occasional delicateness of the harps, mirrors the otherworldliness of the Holst that opened the programme, this cyclical programming shrouding the concert in an unearthly glow.

Featured Image: Maximus McCabe-Abel