Bazball, boldness and bottling: what we learned from England’s Test match in Rawalpindi
By Sanjay Suri
England’s first Test match in Pakistan since 2005 was one of the most unusual matches we’ve seen in recent years. A flat, dry, bare pitch in Rawalpindi allowed England to score at a speed normally seen in ODIs or T20s, with three players, including Ben Duckett, playing his first test for six years, scoring rapid centuries.
However, the match appeared to be heading for a draw, before a bold declaration from England threw the cat amongst the pigeons, with Jack Leach snatching victory at the death as the sun was setting. The ‘Bazball era’ is well and truly alive and kicking, but how long for?
Bazball continues to get results
Whilst Pakistan are not the Test superpower they once were, and were missing star bowler Shaheen Shah Afridi, this is undoubtably a huge win for England. They have struggled in away Tests in recent years, especially on subcontinental pitches, and by taking initiative in the match put them in a position where winning was in contention.
Their swashbuckling, counter-attacking batting performances since Brendon McCullum took over as head coach in May has seen them beat New Zealand and South Africa 3-0 and 2-1 respectively, as well as a thrilling victory versus India in a one-off Test in Edgbaston. Yet there were still doubts whether it would work away from home, or against tougher opponents.
Stokes and his team have certainly responded to those critics in emphatic fashion. Victory should never have been possible, but their quick scoring basically bought them an extra day to get the 20 Pakistani wickets they required. Had they batted traditionally, a draw would have been inevitable. Instead, they are celebrating just their third ever Test win in Pakistan.
This is undoubtably a huge win for England
But is it sustainable?
Bazball worked this time, but does that mean it will always work? It was very easy to implement on a Rawalpindi pitch that played like a road with little deterioration across the five days. Winning the toss meant that they could take risks as they were very unlikely to lose batting first, even if they had an underwhelming first innings.
Furthermore, this was very much a Pakistani bowling attack with little firepower. Afridi was missing due to a long-term knee injury and three of the four front-line bowlers were making their Test debut, with Naseem Shah being the only one with Test experience. England’s next series is away in New Zealand in February. Would the likes of Trent Boult and Tim Southee be so easy to take on?
We have already seen signs of Bazball failing. South Africa won the first Test in their series against England by an innings, with Ollie Pope being the only player to score more than 40 across the two England innings. They tried, they failed. In that Test, the batters tried to intimidate Kagiso Rabada and Anrich Nortje. These two South Africa quicks are not easily intimidated, and one could say England were foolish to try.
However, an ‘all-out-attack’ approach evidently has its place in Test cricket. Here it was clearly the right tactic and ended up being the winning tactic. The scoreboard pressure could have resulted in Pakistan getting nowhere near England’s total in the first innings, setting up a more comfortable and commanding victory, but it was thanks to Babar Azam and Pakistan’s grit that they were able to get close to England’s first innings score of 657.
Ben the Bold
England declared at tea on day four, setting Pakistan 343 to win, at under four an over, on a batting friendly pitch. This decision meant that the match was on a knife-edge, with all four results in play. Pundits and commentators expected England to bat for another hour in the evening session, putting victory beyond Pakistan, and giving themselves three and a half sessions to take ten wickets.
But Stokes, who admitted that his team would try to avoid draws as much as possible, stuck to his word and rolled the dice. When Leach claimed Naseem Shah’s scalp, the light was fading rapidly, meaning play could be stopped at any moment. I doubt England would have been able to bowl more than two more overs.
The gamble worked, but just because something works it does not necessarily mean it was the right decision. We all want to see exciting cricket, but Stokes risked everything for it. Had Pakistan not collapsed in the final session, a home victory was very much on the cards, and would have been humiliating for England, given that they had controlled the contest for the first three and a half days.
Once again it comes down to taking risks at the right time. It is good to see aggressive captaincy, but this was almost reckless. Certainly, England bowled well to instigate the collapse, but the feeling in the Pakistani dressing room will be that they let victory slip through their fingers after it had been presented to them by Stokes.
An ‘all-out-attack’ approach evidently has its place in Test cricket
Poor, predictable pitches
The track at Rawalpindi is starting to get a reputation. The pitch was simply too easy to bat on. It was flat, it had absolutely no grass cover, and the bounce was predictable as the pitch was not cracking or deteriorating with time and usage. This Test was no exception either.
For the last two years, Rawalpindi’s pitch has been as flat as the Grand Trunk Road that runs through this historic city. A top international venue needs to be held to higher standards to create exciting Tests. Their blushes were spared by England’s batting and Stokes’ gamble, but a pitch where a draw is most likely after five days of play is not fit to host international cricket.
We have now seen matches that have lasted under three days and matches where batting has dominated. A middle ground can be found. It was especially unfortunate that the simultaneous match between Australia and West Indies resulted in two double centuries for the Baggy Greens, who reached 598-4 declared in the first innings. However, unlike Pakistan, West Indies crumbled, resulting in an Aussie triumph. It still does not hide the fact that the pitch was too easy to bat on.
How do we solve this then? It is understandable if it is a one-off, but this is just happening too frequently. Currently, teams can be docked World Test Championship points if their pitch is inadequate, but in reality, the ICC need to be proactive, not reactive. Having regular checks by ICC officials before a match is hosted could work, but that will cost time and money. It could also result in pitches becoming too similar to each other, robbing us of an exciting element of Test series’.
Big-hitting Brook
Harry Brook was undoubtably the star of the show, getting the third fastest ever Test century in the first innings, then falling for 87 in the second. He was the epitome of Bazball in this Test and seemed impossible to bowl at. His 360-degree hitting was his highlight and the Yorkshire lad looked very much at home in the middle-order.
Brook will be giving McCullum serious selection headaches come June. Will he fit in the team properly once Jonny Bairstow returns from injury? However, one must not get carried away. Whilst Brook has been superb and appears to have the right temperament for a cricketer, we have seen many flashes in the pan in the last ten years. Brook will earn a regular place in the team through consistency, not one-off performances
Rawalpindi’s pitch has been as flat as the Grand Trunk Road
What now?
There are two more Tests in the series, with the next one in Multan starting on Friday. An away series win is tantalisingly close for England, but they still have a lot of work to do to wrap it up. Pakistan will come out of the blocks fighting, with many of their batters looking like they are starting to find form, especially Azam.
Keeping Azam quiet will be the storyline to watch. Jimmy Anderson will relish the challenge, as will Stokes, who loves the big moments. Azam is the player who can single-handedly take this series away from England, so if he offers a chance, it needs to be taken.
Bazball is working, and there is no indication that it will stop working anytime in Pakistan. It should result in exciting cricket, one way or another. Maybe it is worth waking up at 5 in the morning to watch the start of the Test. Set your alarms, because these performances are not one to miss.
Image: Luke McKernan via Flickr

