Banning the burqa would be a catalyst for racism and intolerance
Liberté, égalité and fraternité are three terms you would not use to characterise French society at the moment.
A national identity crisis caused by immigration and decades of industrial decline means that insecurity – and the corresponding attempt to preserve national ‘republican values’ – have caused many people to turn against what they see as the cause of the problem: the largest Muslim population in Europe.
The ban on wearing the burqa, enacted in 2011, was not only a result of this growing intolerance; it has actually made the situation worse. Muslim groups have reported a rise in physical and verbal assaults on women in veils, as racial bigots see their opinions represented in law. This increase in violence – alongside the absurdity of allowing politicians to dictate the personal clothing choices of the public – should persuade Britain of the need to avoid following the French example.
Hind Ahmas, 32, a divorced single mother of a three-year-old daughter, made the personal decision to wear the veil as an expression of her faith. She has refused to obey the new law, and has subsequently been punched in the face by thugs outside her home in Paris, and sent to prison after refusing to accept a police fine.
She told The Guardian: “My quality of life has seriously deteriorated since the ban. In my head, I have to prepare for war every time I step outside, prepare to come up against people who want a bullet in my head.
“The politicians claimed they were liberating us; what they’ve done is to exclude us from the social sphere.”
Supporters of a ban on burqas in Britain, such as the Daily Telegraph journalist Allison Pearson, frequently defend their opinion on the basis that veils are “misogynistic.” However, this view fails to comprehend that women like Hind are in the majority – they have elected to wear the veil as a personal choice. Indeed, an Open Society Foundation report in France found that out of a sample of 32 women who wore the niqab (the full length veil) none had been forced to do so.
The veil ban in France is just one aspect of an increasingly toxic approach to race relations in the country. The National Front (FN) has the support of nearly a quarter of the electorate, and the government continues to pursue the expulsion of Roma gypsies, which has been condemned as a “disgrace” by the European Commission. Underlying this is what France’s first black television newsreader, Harry Roselmack, described as a “deep-seated racism”; a hostility that led to the justice minister being targeted with monkey chants as she walked down the street. The FN’s reaction to this? An electoral candidate saying that she would “rather see her in the trees” than in the government.
The ban on the burqa can therefore only be seen as the product of a society riven with insecurity and racial tension. Yet it has not even achieved much: fines against women are rare, as police are either keen to focus on more important matters, or are wary of action by the European Court of Human Rights. Also, the law is a ridiculously crass solution to what is in fact an extremely minor issue – only 2000 women in France actually wear the niqab.
With 61 per cent of the British population in favour of banning the burqa according to a YouGov poll for The Sun, defending the right of people to wear the clothes they want may not be popular. However, as a nation we pride ourselves on our tolerance and respect for individual freedom, and such a ban would be fundamentally un-British.
A ban on burqas would turn the law into a weapon of intolerance, fill up our courtrooms with unnecessary cases and cause violence on our streets. Just like bidets and dog droppings, we should leave this nasty policy firmly on the other side of the Channel.
Photograph: Chuy Benitez


