Balotelli: to swap or not to swap?
By George Breare
For a club that so readily supported Luis Suarez amidst allegations of racism, diving and biting; Liverpool’s reaction to Mario Balotelli’s ill-advised half-time shirt swap with Pepe in the club’s Champions League clash with Real Madrid seems rather disproportionate to the crime.
If Twitter is to be believed, Balotelli’s actions were of heinous proportions. However, it is hard not to see the entire episode as a handy scapegoat to cover a team’s poor start to the season. It is perhaps no coincidence that Liverpool were trailing 3-0 with no foothold in the game when the criticism was at its most vociferous.
It is somewhat reminiscent of a similar incident in 2012 when Arsenal’s Andre Santos swapped shirts at half-time with Robin van Persie in the aftermath of his controversial summer move to Manchester United. Similarly Arsenal were trailing 1-0 after the unthinkable happened in a van Persie goal. Again, Santos was used as an unfortunate scapegoat to divert attention from the shortcomings of the team.
It was certainly an ill-timed move. Journalists and fans alike readily accept the custom of exchanging shirts at the end of games but the same act at half-time produces outrage. This exposes a key contrast in the mentality of the player and the supporter.
For a fan, the game is fundamentally partisan and we want the player’s to feel the same levels of passion and, at times, hatred for the opposition. However, for a player, the game is played in a more professional mindset. Following the public outrage, Santos himself admitted as much: “Robin’s departure to United did not turn him into an enemy for me”. Pictures of players back-slapping their compatriots or former team-mates in the tunnel before a game further demonstrates this, much to the ire of many fans.
The fall-out from the Balotelli incident has also been driven enormously by the media. Mark Lawrenson’s assertion that it was a moment of “sheer madness” is sensationalism at its finest and continues with the Balotelli narrative that dominates the football press at the moment. His prior troubles at Manchester City and AC Milan have led to people waiting to pounce on a supposed lack of application and loyalty and with the half-time shirt swap, Balotelli has given them a story on a platter.
Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers was critical of the incident saying “it is not something I stand for. If you want to do that do it at the end of the game.” This hits the crux of the issue: it is not just the fact that it was done at half time that is the issue, but the fact it was done in the Anfield tunnel, in front of a live television of millions.
There is of course the positive aspect of shirt swapping. Few will begrudge the pure delight on Jack Wilshere’s face after exchanging shirts with Barcelona’s Xavi and Iniesta after a Champions League win in 2011. It is also a sign of mutual respect after the heat of battle on the pitch.
Balotelli’s actions certainly did not merit the abuse and criticism he received afterwards. Whilst it was certainly ill-advised and his timing leaves a lot to be desired, it was a fairly innocent mistake; a mistake that is a handy distraction from a woeful performance from Liverpool on their Champions League return.
Photograph: wikipedia

