ASHES BLOG: Trott’s sad departure adds to England’s problems

ASHES BLOG

By Nick Friend

Even without the unfortunate news of the departure of Jonathan Trott, England would have had some thinking to do before the second test in Adelaide.

They have a batting line-up with frailties throughout and a bowling attack looking less than threatening after the Kookaburra ball loses its shine.

The Australians on the other hand, are acting like spoilt schoolchildren on their birthday. Having not won a test throughout the whole of 2013, it would appear that the ‘hosts’ have forgotten how to do so with some sort of class and dignity.

England’s biggest issue is, without doubt, with the bat. What magnifies the problem is the fact that Michael Clarke and his bowlers seem to have a simple plan for each and every one of them. It’s not as if they’ve been ‘gotten out’ by excellent bowling. All barring Carberry have known what would come their way and then fallen for the tactics set in place.

Alastair Cook knows that Ryan Harris will keep it on a length on and around his fourth stump in the knowledge, Jonathan Trott – whose mindset was clearly affected by the stress-related illness that has cut short his tour – was bounced out in both innings. Kevin Pietersen, in his 100th test, was dismissed by two different field placements but with one common factor. The Aussies played on KP’s ego, putting two men on the drive at short-midwicket, and then two out on the hook in the second innings.

England's Jonathan Trott, who has been forced to leave the tour due to stress-related illness.
England’s Jonathan Trott, who has been forced to leave the tour due to stress-related illness

Matt Prior has become a major concern for England. His keeping is still as solid as ever, but much like his reserve in Jonny Bairstow, he seems to have a serious issue with the full and straight delivery.

In the bowling department, Messrs Broad and Anderson were superb – the former taking the wickets with Jimmy bowling incredibly economically on such a flat surface.

The problem lay with the other half of the four-pronged attack. Chris Tremlett did adequately but no more. For a man built like a tank and standing at 6ft 8in, Cook could have been forgiven for wanting more hostility. Although he did little ‘wrong’, Steven Finn must come into the side in Adelaide. Mitchell Johnson has already shown the advantage of a genuine quick bowler – regardless of where he sprays it.

The savage attack on Graeme Swann from Australia’s batsmen is what would give the most cause for concern in terms of team selection from here on in. Swann dominated the series in England mainly because Khawaja, Rogers, Hughes, North and Hussey (in series gone by) and Warner are all left-handers – the prey on which Swann usually pounces.

This time around, only Warner and Rogers remain and Warner played the off-spinner like a club 3rd XI spinner. Add this to the fact that Swann doesn’t bowl with much of the overspin, which created so much bounce and sharper turn for Nathan Lyon and even Steve Smith, Swann shouldn’t play. It would be better to go with Panesar given his record against right-handers and on how poorly Swann bowled – dragging it short and then too full in equal measure.

With Trott’s upsetting departure from the tour leaving the team a batsman short, the XI for Adelaide should be: Cook, Carberry, Bell, Pietersen, Root, Stokes, Prior, Broad, Finn, Anderson, Panesar. Regardless of England’s selection, they will need to be ten times better. If so, I’d still back them as strong favourites to take the series 3-1.

Photograph: Nic Redhead