As You Like It review: ‘strong effort’

Alex Tansey (Orlando)
Alex Tansey (Orlando)

By Alexander James Hall

Outdoor Shakespeare, like Pimms, Wimbledon and horse racing, is a true staple of the Great British summer. However, that other dependable staple, the Great British drizzle, dampened what otherwise would have been a delightful afternoon in Trevelyan College’s quad. Hill College Theatre Company’s production of As You Like It was generally strong with sections of excellence.

As You Like It follows cousins Celia and Rosalind in their banishment from the Ducal court, from which they escape into the woods to engage in copious amounts of cross-dressing and tangled love hexagons seemingly demanded by any Shakespearian comedy. First-time director Rachael Smith has developed an unusual interpretation of the bard’s work, reimagining it “transported to the 1960s, documenting the struggle between capitalism and bohemianism”. Whilst this interpretation was aesthetically charming, assisted by the handsome period costumes of Megha Mittal, the overall effect of the production was that of a rejection of the capitalist court, in favor of the bohemian woods, rather than an ongoing conflict between the 60s high and counter culture.

Several performances were worthy of note, the most exceptional being Nick Denton’s Touchstone, the Court Fool. Denton was magnificent throughout; his mimicry and mockery of the other characters and impeccable bouncy physicality endeared him to the hearts of the audience, claiming the few laugh-out-loud moments as his own. His energy was almost as zesty as that of Eleanor Stephens as Celia, who through her consistent effort kept the audience amused whenever she was on stage. Rosalind, portrayed by Naoise Murphy, carried off the cross-dressing with ease and her transformation from courtier to woodland bride was convincing. Joseph Kelen was possibly presented with the most difficult task, for though As You Like It is not one of Shakespeare’s most celebrated works, it arguably contains some of his most famous speeches. A fine example was the ‘All the world’s a stage’ monologue in which Kelen set about transforming the heavy time-worn words into being as light and jovial as the rest of the play via an original delivery and an inspired bite of an apple at its conclusion.

These strong performances only served to illuminate the weaker members of the cast.  JJ Bute’s portrayal of Adam, the old man, was unconvincing due to his lack of committal to his characterization; merely hunching over does not convey the pain and decrepidness that only cruel winters can bring. Jenny Hudec’s three characterizations as Dennis, Hymen and Sir Oliver were all sound, however lacked clear distinction between them. This could easily be said for the majority of the multi-rolling members of the cast for the lack of distinction made the opening court scenes quite confusing to someone not familiar with the plot, which was not assisted by the minimal courtly costume variation.

Smith’s choice of Trevs’ quad as the venue helped embody the unusual overall interpretation as the monumental 1960s brutalism of the walls of Trevs symbolized the straight-jacketed world of the court, whilst the lush delicate foliage of the gardens conjured the bohemian woods in a way that no painted backdrop could muster. Though the weather did not join in with the frivolity we were treated to two feathered visitors halfway through the first act. The use of live musicians playing Elizabethan-esque pastoral pieces was a pleasant nod to the seventeenth century origins of the play and covered some of the transitions. However, the decision not to fully integrate them with the rest of the performers neither by their costumes nor direction ensured that their exits and entrances were jarring and interrupted the flow of the performance.

Transitions more broadly left much to be desired, as long pauses at the beginning and end of scenes became almost uncomfortable and there was a distinct lack of consistency as some actors performed their set changes and exits in character, whilst others attempted to be neutral. The overall effect was messy which cut across the flow of the play and prevented the audience from truly relaxing into this imaginary world. This was in stark contrast to the wonderful flow of the main action within the scenes. This was complemented by mimed sub plots between actors, a prime example being Jacques teasing Celia with a vintage camera, which added great visual variety and prevented the long speeches from becoming static.

As You Like It was a strong effort from HCTC with some standout performances and wonderful moments. Definitely worth a watch, but a trusty umbrella should be considered as essential as a picnic hamper, champagne, and strawberries for maximum enjoyment.

Photo: Ollie Tallis