Artists against the Ebacc
Tracey Emin, Professor of Drawing at the Royal Academy, has warned that inner city riots will resurface if Arts are not a core part of the government’s education reforms. Though Emin’s predictions of lawlessness and anarchy might be a little far-fetched, she does draw attention to the alarming dismissal of art in schools today. Art is not included in any of the five subject areas of the new English Baccalureate (or EBacc) and will therefore be dropped as a core constituent of a rounded education.
Emin told The Independent, “if art isn’t considered as important as other subjects it will just fall by the wayside”. She added that it “cannot be a secondary subject”, suggesting that with no creative outlet at schools, inner-city school children might turn to violence. Emin cites her work with teenagers, saying that she found using the arts to challenge them had a positive outcome.
The Turner Prize-winning artist, most famous for her installation ‘My Bed’, is a member of the Tate establishment and its campaign to keep Art in the national curriculum. The campaign seeks to raise the arts to the same level of recognition as traditional academic subjects such as Maths and English.
Introduced in 2011, the Ebacc is not yet a formal qualification, but a performance measure of academic subjects at GCSE level. However, Michael Gove announced last year that the Ebacc would replace GCSEs in the appropriate subjects by 2015. To achieve the qualification, 15 and 16 year olds must have an A* – C grade in each of the five constituent areas of learning; Maths, English, Languages, Science and Humanities.
Emin is just one of many visual artists who have opposed this marginalisation of art in the school curriculum. The Director of Tate, Sir Nicholas Serota, is among the notable figures who have criticised Gove’s reforms.
Despite this campaign, the Department for Education has stated that it has no intention of changing the subjects which count towards the EBacc. In an effort to pander to league tables, it is feared that schools will encourage students to choose subjects part of the EBacc rather than those not formally recognised. Critics also argue that it discriminates against those with talent in the creative arts. Our education system should not be one in which students with certain abilities are favoured over those with flair in more unconventionally academic subjects.
Patrick Brill, a visual artist preferring the pseudonym ‘Bob and Roberta Smith’, is renowned for his pithy, politically charged use of words rendered in bright colours. He has composed an open letter to Michael Gove that highlights how formative art is for the education of children, sharply criticising the “assault on Arts”. Brill suggests that arts are an integral part of our identities and, indeed, the identity of Britain itself. He warns that belittling art in the EBacc system and taking Art of the national curriculum will “emasculate British Culture”.
The Vice-Chancellor of UAL (University of the Arts London), Nigel Carrington, spoke out about the deep concern of university officials at the exclusion of art from the curriculum in a letter to The Times newspaper. He cites a Department for Education survey which reports that 17% of English secondary schools have already dropped the teaching of Art.
Both Bob and Roberta Smith and Carrington advise that the arts play a crucial role in Britain’s economy. Art is not simply an ineffectual and unprofitable exercise, beginning at school with children covering themselves with poster paint during ‘doss’ lessons. The ‘Bacc for the Future’ campaign reports that Britain’s creative industries employ two million people and contribute 6% of GDP.
Bob and Roberta Smith poetically raises this point in his letter: “Everything is visual. Art, yes but also design, money, numbers: even the ebb and flow of commerce has to be made visual.”
The Department of Education excludes art from the core subjects yet its statement of intent for the EBacc is to encourage study of subjects preferred for entry to degree courses and employment. There is an explicit conflict between the government and the art world in their priorities for education and the growth and success of Britain.
It can only be a bad thing if Britain’s artists of the future – whether they are architects, designers, engineers, technicians – cannot be given the necessary education. Visual Art has just as much to say for itself as any other subject; especially if it were encouraged in the EBacc context of a broad range of subjects.
Image Courtesy of the Artist and Hales Gallery, London. Copyright of the Artist.

