Art must be more than merely sensationalist

Art

By Madeleine Brown

 

Part of the developmental experience of studying at university is beginning to question our ideas and traditions, and learning to communicate with each other; a process by which we realise that we have shared interests and concerns about our society. Students are in the unique position of often being asked to reflect on the future challenges of their society. And as young, free, confident individuals, we are known for our innovative and sometimes downright outrageous attempts to draw attention to whatever topical issue has temporarily engaged our interest.

Recently, Clayton Pettet, a nineteen-year-old art student at Central St. Martins, has announced his plans for his ‘performance art project’ that he reckons will receive rave reviews for challenging contemporary perceptions of sexuality. The project, ‘Art School Stole My Virginity’, features Pettet having sex with his partner for the first time in front of a gallery of 50 to 100 spectators, followed by a Question and Answer session.

Although the performance is part of a graded school project, Pettet’s underlying desire to execute such a piece probably extends much further than mere mark grabbing. (It will be interesting to see the grading criteria for this project, and whether or not sheer exhibitionism will compensate for insufficient development of ideas).

He claims that the purpose of his piece is to draw attention to the cultural perception of ‘virginity’, which has become ‘heteronormative’ in its definition. He also aims to challenge associated traditional views, opening up an interesting debate about wider issues concerning gender and sexuality. “My piece isn’t a statement as much as it is a question.” Pettet asks, “Is virginity even real?”

He supposedly first conceived the idea for this piece aged 16 when his peers were beginning to lose their virginities as part of their sexual development. Pettet, on the other hand, decided to make better use of his own, saving it for “altruistic” purposes in his art.

However, many have questioned whether this planned piece actually constitutes ‘art’, leading us back to the age-old philosophical debate: what is art, anyway? If art is the production of visually-pleasing aesthetics, requiring some degree of skill and experience on the part of the artist, then no, this performance does not qualify.

But if we take a more modern conception of art, meriting it on concept, ideas and the confrontation of convention, then Pettet’s piece will definitely succeed in achieving the shock factor now typical of contemporary artistic practices. Personally, I think it’s a great shame that the conception of Visual Arts has degenerated from the highly-esteemed rigorous academic pursuit of the past to the publicity-driven, sensationalist, commercial model of the contemporary art world.

it’s a great shame that the conception of Visual Arts has degenerated from the highly-esteemed rigorous academic pursuit of the past to the publicity-driven, sensationalist, commercial model of the contemporary art world

Furthermore, Pettet has received heavy criticism from social groups. A spokeswoman for the Lesbian and Gay Christian movement has termed the project a “stunt” that degrades “the special relationship of sex between loving partners.” I would be inclined to go further, and identify the work as essentially an act of pornography (interestingly, the online dictionary defines pornography as obscene visual material ‘having little or no artistic merit’).

Although our society in general disapproves of pornography for its core values and the detrimental implications it has in society, I wouldn’t be completely averse to its use in art to challenge social norms. However, I think Pettet’s piece is naïve and confused, his concept lacking sufficient reflection and development to justify the use of such a contentious and potentially offensive medium.

It would seem that the predominant motive behind his planned performance is more a desperate, sensationalist attempt to make his name, attract unwarranted attention, and proclaim his ‘message’ to the world. Alas, another unfortunate product of the contemporary art world.

Illustration: Cressida Peever