Arming the police is not in the public interest

by David Siesage

If you go to Europe regularly, you will be accustomed to seeing their police officers walking around with huge guns. ‘But these are foreign countries’, we think – ‘they might need this level of force’. Surely, in lovely Blighty, our emergency services would have no need for such measures? The rare sight of a British bobby with a gun has always been an unnerving and sinister one – a reminder of an Orwellian, oppressive state that we try at all costs to avoid.

This state of affairs has continued at home without comment, regardless of our experiences abroad and to the surprise of some tourists. That is, until September 18th, when PCs Nicola Hughes and Fiona Bone were sent on a routine call out in Manchester where they were shot dead. In the following days, the murky issue of firearms has once again resurfaced.

Many have come out in favour of arming the police. The former chairman of Essex Police Federation, Tony Rayner, and Michael Winner, (film director, sometime insurance advert irritant and founder of the Police Memorial Trust), have both expressed the need for police officers to be ‘routinely armed’, and they are not alone. A 2004 poll conducted by ICM discovered that 47% of the British public supported arming all police and the recent events certainly will not have reduced that figure.

Thankfully, those involved with the incident have remained level-headed about the approach of the British bobby. The Chief Constable of the Greater Manchester Police Force Sir Peter Fahy confirmed, “We are passionate that the British style of policing is routinely unarmed policing. Sadly we know from the experience in America and other countries that having armed officers certainly does not mean…that police officers do not end up getting shot” – a view reinforced by a 2006 survey which indicated that 82% of police officers were averse to being ‘routinely armed’.

Of course, the police have firearms units which can be deployed in particularly dangerous situations and armed police have begun to appear a little more frequently in recent years, especially around airports since 9/11. This is not America though, and as a result, only 5% of officers are authorised to use guns, and this is how it should stay. Armed police must continue to be deployed in only the most extreme scenarios, not on a day to day basis. We still have a comparatively low gun crime rate, which is currently at its lowest in years.

And now for some Daily Mail-esque scare mongering: what would be the longer term consequences of an armed police force? In my opinion, even the most conservative predictions are worrying.

We do not want to make guns an everyday thing. The sight of a firearm should still shock, but arming police officers simply reduces the stigma around firearms and makes guns more commonplace. Whilst most young children only see fictional characters like Action Man wielding firearms nowadays, bring them to the streets and it becomes a very different story.

And what is to stop the criminals taking the necessary precautions against them, and arming themselves in the same fashion? An ‘if they have them, why can’t I?’ attitude could well emerge. From the petty criminal to gangland overlord, what criminal would take the risk of being inappropriately armed against his enemies?

We have seen that even with a limited access to firearms, our trusted police force can make horrible mistakes. Incidents like the shootings of Jean Charles de Menezes and Mark Duggan (the latter of which sparked the awful riots of last summer) would certainly not be less likely if armed police were standard. The scrutiny of the police after the both the Menezes and the Duggan affair was intense, and not something either the police or the public would like to repeat.

Giving police officers guns implies a level of distrust between the police and general public which is just not there. The British police have always been generally accepted and respected by the public, and arming them would replace all this respect with a rule of fear, undermining the principle of policing by consent. As, Richard Garside, director of the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies, bluntly and aptly put, “There’s a general recognition that if the police are walking around with guns it changes things.”

Arming our entire police force, therefore, is an extremely flawed proposal. As tragic as the deaths of the two police officers were, we must not look to ill thought out and knee-jerk responses to satiate our anger and hurt. As horrible as it is, police officers will always be putting their lives at risk to some extent when they are on duty, and that chance does not diminish when you put a gun in their hands.