Are we going to further alienate immigrants from the UK?
By Dite Bagdonaite
The Nationality and Borders Bill, which last week passed its first reading in the House of Lords, follows a worrying and unsurprising trend of recent Conservative policy. The gradual increase of discretionary powers afforded to ministers should disrupt everyone’s inertia, even the nine per cent of British adults polled by YouGov who believe we should not allow anyone fleeing persecution or war to live in the UK. Libertarians and leftists alike should be united in furore against the measures.
The Bill does not just miss the mark when it comes to its aim of ‘[making] the system fairer and more effective’, it immunises officials from the law. Alongside the outline of immigration officials’ pushback powers, the Bill removes criminal and civil liability when a refugee dies during such an operation. The anti-refugee zeitgeist we are currently living through reframes the requirement for ‘good faith’ and ‘reasonable grounds’ where death occurs into mere administrative hurdles.
Stateless and without rights
If the deaths of migrants crossing the Channel are not enough to incense you, the Bill could as readily be weaponised much closer to home. The Clause 9 amendment establishes the mechanism for the deprivation of citizenship and is ominously vague, affording significant discretion to the Home Office – an institution plagued by its history of mishandling, Windrush serving as an especially pertinent example. In Orwellian fashion, ideas of ‘public interest’ are manipulated for politically expedient application. Practicality dictates that the Government need not even provide notice of an individual’s deprivation of citizenship. The increasing subjectivity and need for judgement in the application of the law facilitates, contrary to the government’s claims, an ability to render an individual stateless and without rights. Comfortingly, the Bill prescribes a watertight appeals process: ‘An individual can seek to exercise their statutory right to appeal against the decision – even if not aware of their deprivation at the time’.
While proponents of the Bill argue it will not be applied to non-immigrant people, its use will inevitably reverberate across immigrant communities. The fortification of a hostile environment is not something to be proud of. The Office of National Statistics data indicating that two in every five people from non-white ethnic minorities will be affected by the Bill should appal and shock everyone. However, the majority of the British public has become desensitised to xenophobic and racist rhetoric and uninspired by the furore which responds to it.
While commentators across the political spectrum opine on the Bill, migration policy is symbiotically attached to the quality of life accessible to a person and has a breadth of consequences. Mermaids, a charity which supports gender non-conforming and transgender young people, raised concerns that temporary protection status, for example, may force many trans people to hide their gender identity in the UK in case of return to their country of origin.
Restricted in their ability to integrate
The creation of temporary protection status does not meet the standard of care which should be afforded to refugees and asylum-seekers. Its being subject to renewal every 30 months does not provide a stable basis upon which to build a life in the UK. The Government is emphatic in its assurance that the Bill does not change any existing rights, but it is undeniable that its enactment would greatly reduce them going forward. They have no recourse to public funds but are restricted in their ability to integrate economically, further propagating the ‘burdensome refugee’ image the Government has created
For a party which lambasts procedure, the proposals which complement the Bill create a lot of it. In October, Dominic Raab told Sky News that the Government would “look, at least, at possibilities of international partnerships” to help process asylum claims – unsubtle code for flying Channel-crossing migrants to Albania within seven days of arrival in Britain. While somewhat less farcical than its Ascension Island scheme, this plan’s purported deterrent function is rooted in anti-Albanian sentiment and frustrates, as opposed to streamlines, asylum claims.
Last week, the Government announced new sanctions against those involved in human rights violations in Myanmar and Pakistan. Why, then, persecute and prosecute those who seek to escape them?
Image: Blake Guidry via Unsplash

