Are war profiteers and pandemic profiteers in the same league?

By Sophie Farmer

As COVID-19 mortality rates in the UK gradually decline, the last few months remind us what role community, hard work and perseverance have played in acting as the cornerstone to our nation. That said, many have suffered financially in this current recession, and have had to resort to alternate means to support themselves and their families.

Simultaneously, however, there has been the rise of a sub-culture of sorts; ‘pandemic profiteers’ to coin a term for this subset of Western society, have indeed capitalized on the market demands of a global crisis. The trading of PPE kit, medication, and general safety equipment i.e. masks, protective gloves, and hand sanitiser has left some with an ethically disputable profit. To what extent does virtue come into play with the prospect of profiting on such a dreadful global crisis?

Hand sanitiser prices have increased on average by 367% during the period

War profiteering, chiefly during WWI and WWII, saw private contractors’ profit margins increase by the hundreds, even thousands. In the Second Reading of a ‘Profiteering Bill’ in 1919, Sir Auckland Geddes employed the analogy of businessmen sourcing the cheapest boots they could secure and selling them for even more; shoddy boots that would then be worn by soldiers on the frontline. Countless ethical and economical implications arise from this. By definition, war profiteering is generally applied to a business procuring ‘unreasonable’ profit margins, though what might be deemed a significant profit for a one-man business may be negligible to a retail tycoon. Yet the act remains the same. The profits, inevitably, will vary.

The big dogs of retail like Amazon and eBay have been guilty of selling PPE kit for extortionate prices. I recall looking on Amazon just before lockdown was announced and finding that the only available hand sanitisers were marketed at £40 upwards. It seemed unjust that a multibillion-dollar business was using its network to profit at the expense of a vulnerable consumer market.

On platforms with everyday users such as Facebook and Depop, I noticed people sell the aforementioned products for substantial prices that clearly covered the cost of raw materials and would leave room for significant profit margins as a result. In truth, most of the time the descriptions alongside these products would be detailing that some or all profits were going towards the NHS and public services — still a considerable number still did not outline this.

You may even remember in the early days of the pandemic when local shops were advertising hand sanitiser for £20.00, when 2 months earlier one could probably purchase the same bottle for £6.50. This price gouging is similarly mirrored in the Competition and Markets Authority’s reports revealing that hand sanitiser prices have increased on average by 367% during the period. This may not seem like the most pertinent of issues, yet as the virus is gradually suppressed, these pricing margins are passing under the mainstream radar.

The pandemic market thus begets a perpetual cycle of consumer exploitation

Can morally questionable trade be justified by the background of the vender? What if there is a redundant person struggling to make ends meet in this climate, who by chance is skilled with a sewing machine, can make protective face masks and sell them for £4 each? Some may argue that even in this instance it would be morally ‘right’ to donate a small percentage of sales revenue to charity — to those actively containing and nursing the virus’ devastation. At the same time, this person will likely be the consumer unknowingly exploited by supermarket price gouging when purchasing £2.50 RRP Andrex at a 60% increase at £4.00. The pandemic market thus begets a perpetual cycle of consumer exploitation.

At present, there are limited government restraints on these undertakings, as in March 2020 Boris Johnson stated in the House of Commons that new laws were needed to tackle this “profiteering”. While one government official repudiated this claim saying that this was “not something we are actively pursuing at the moment”.

I appreciate this economic observation is not the most pressing issue we as a nation face, for ample attention should be focused on the BLM movement and remembering the victims of the Coronavirus. However, efforts to ameliorate the current protective measures should be pursued, if not for consumer protection, for the preservation of ethics.

Image: James Smith