Are the PureGym findings all that pure?
By Oliver Jervis
Durham’s sports scene is revered across the country and beyond for its high-quality output. As much can be observed from the list of alumni the University is constantly able to churn out, whether it be in the form of gold medal winning Olympians (a nod towards Jonathon Edwards & more), Commonwealth champions, or rising stars such as BUCS Super Rugby all-time try-scorer Fred Davies.
Moreover, it can also be seen in the recent Good University Guide produced by The Times. This position of athletic notoriety across the metaphorical field of sport has only been reinforced by the recent findings of PureGym, suggesting that Team Durham is a force to be reckoned with for any university in the United Kingdom – even in the eyes of the likes of Oxford, Cambridge and high-flyers Loughborough.
Yet, questions remain regarding the culture presently residing within the visually merry climes of Maiden Castle’s many courts and pitches. Earlier this year, a Palatinate investigation revealed that serious issues had corrupted the University’s elite sports teams, with claims of ‘racism, elitism and intimidation’ arising.
Thus, this is evidently a body with fundamental problems that require an effective solution. As an organisation operating on the frontline of student sport, Team Durham must ask itself what it values more: ceaseless successful performances in the BUCS rankings accompanied by an intensely toxic culture, or an environment more accustomed to the ethical values consistently preached about by the University in their emails with undetermined results?
Questions remain regarding the culture presently residing within the visually merry climes of Maiden Castle’s many courts and pitches
When observing the current response to the issues of the day infesting Maiden Castle, one builds the impression that the former approach is presently preferred by Team Durham. One issue that requires particular addressal is accessibility.
Due to the turmoil surrounding the aforementioned claims concerning Durham’s elite sports teams, this specific matter has seemingly been neglected by the powers that be. In essence, it is deserving of a lot more attention – especially in the light of PureGym’s recent glorifying study.
To provide ample context, in the closing weeks of the last academic year Durham’s 93% Club (a student group aiming to help state students at university level) ran a ‘cut the costs’ campaign which sought to address this accessibility problem.
With the intention of securing an effective solution for underprivileged students, they tendered an open letter to the University providing several proposals seeking to remedy the inequalities currently presiding at Maiden Castle.

These included the imposition of a means-tested subsidy similar to the college-level participation fund, an expansion of sports-related grants aimed at those starting at novice-level, and an increase in effective dialogue between Team Durham and students when it came to matters like financial accessibility.
When asked by Palatinate regarding Team Durham’s response to this campaign, Luke Alsford – last year’s 93% Club President – said: “The 93% Club’s campaign was acknowledged, but not acted upon. We know from communications with multiple Team Durham clubs and from a meeting with Team Durham’s then-President Chris Lennon, that our campaign was acknowledged and the awareness raised of the astronomical costs of Team DU sports (sometimes exceeding £250) was welcomed.
“However, what we learnt from our campaign is that while Team Durham likes to allude to its accessibility and openness, it is stubbornly and single-mindedly focused on developing the sporting talent of those who are already good enough and can afford to participate.”
With this in mind, it is necessary to ask oneself several questions. For example, Team Durham’s motto is notoriously “Inspiring the Extraordinary”. Yet, if these claims are found to be true, who suffices as “extraordinary” nowadays?
At present, this appears to refer to those who can endure the often-overwhelming costs required to participate in the 18 sports offered by the University. Additionally, it does not seem to include the 75% supposedly deterred from joining Team Durham due to their financial demands according to a recent survey by Durham’s 93% Club.
Studies from the likes of PureGym can only paper over the cracks for so long
More questions instead, therefore, hang over the head of the University. In which direction is it seeking to go? At what point is it desirable to promote a real feeling of equality on the student sports scene?
In the midst of an oft-referred to cost-of-living crisis, is it really acceptable for Team Durham to continue to ignore those most in need? Furthermore, from a purely sporting perspective, how much talent is the organisation willing to let go in order to cut its own costs?
Before arriving in Durham, prospective students are promised an El Dorado of opportunity, including the advantages of state-of-the-art sports facilities that are deceivingly portrayed as easily accessible.
Nevertheless, if this current trend of ignorance towards the needy – to put it in a rather Dickensian fashion – is allowed to continue, then a rewriting of Team Durham’s motto and publicity propaganda must happen with immediate effect.
Whether any meaningful action will be taken by the University hierarchy during the upcoming academic year remains to be seen. Meanwhile, studies from the likes of PureGym can only paper over the cracks for so long.
Image: Oliver Jervis

