Are the British public warming to environmentalism?

By Jonty Head

The Green Party were among the UK’s biggest winners in the recent EU elections, becoming Britain’s fourth biggest political presence in Europe. But a note of caution for any environmental enthusiasts who may be reading: this probably says more about the state of the Labour party than it does about the political priorities of the British public.

There is no doubt that the Green Party will be proud of their success in the European elections, and rightly so. With 7 seats and a vote share of 12.1%, they were ahead of the Conservatives (9.1%) and just two percentage points behind Labour. So, is this a sign that attitudes towards the climate are changing? Taking into consideration the recent progress of environmental groups, that might seem to be the obvious conclusion.

The Extinction Rebellion demonstrations made enough noise to give Westminster little choice but to sit up and listen

The Extinction Rebellion protests in London dominated national headlines in April. Following weeks of pink boats, film stars in dungarees and indeed some serious political debate, the UK government declared a climate change emergency. Unlike so many protests, which for all their noble intentions often fail to have any real impact, these demonstrations made enough noise to give Westminster little choice but to sit up and listen.

Earlier in the year, schoolchildren had been making their absence known in the ‘Youth Strikes 4 Climate’, fed up with a lack of action on the part of their parents’ generation. Greta Thunberg, the 16-year-old leader of the movement, was even invited to speak before both the EU and UK parliaments.

Perhaps most importantly of all, the now well documented ‘Attenborough effect’ has, thankfully, ensured that nobody will ever be able to look at a straw again, without imagining the sad eyes of an unfortunate turtle, pleading with them to reconsider their preferred method of cola consumption.

EU elections have always been a chance for voters to ‘stick it to the man’

Surely, then, the success of the Green Party is a reflection of the changing values of voters, courtesy of Frozen Planet and Emma Thompson? Perhaps, but it may have rather more to do with the performance of Labour: finally, a meltdown that the Greens can cheer about.

EU elections have always been a chance for voters to ‘stick it to the man’ and vote for someone other than the two main parties, safe in the knowledge that, on balance, a slightly different UK cohort of MEPs will have less of an impact on their day-to-day lives than an upheaval of Her Majesty’s government. The Greens would always expect to do better in a European vote than in a general election.

Even so, they had just 3 MEPs after the 2014 European poll, so clearly something has changed. The question is, where has all this extra support come from? The Tories suffered what can only be described as a collapse, losing 15 of their 19 seats, but it seems unlikely that many Conservatives would have jumped to quite such a left-leaning ship. The Liberal Democrats, who this time last year could just about cater for their party conference by putting two tables together at Zizzis, disproved the naysayers by earning a 21% vote share. It doesn’t seem that the Greens gained much support from them either.

Which brings us, of course, to the Labour Party.  Surely, in light of the crumbling of their main rivals, this election would be a glorious triumph for Corbyn and co? As it happens, not quite. They were down from 20 MEPs in 2014 to just 10 this time around. A less embarrassing night for them than the Tories, admittedly, but not by much.

the Green Party must keep up its momentum when it does eventually come up against a strong and focussed Labour Party

The Conservatives are in disarray over Brexit, but the position of the Labour party isn’t any clearer. Meanwhile, the Greens were vocal in their desire to remain, and they were rewarded for it. The breakdown of the EU election results shows that, generally speaking, the more pro-Remain an area was during the referendum, the more likely people were to lend their support to the Green Party. Voters who were too left-wing for the Liberal Democrats but too anti-Brexit for Labour had a party to turn to, and they did.

This means that it is too simplistic to put the success of the Green Party simply down to a change in the public’s stance on environmental issues. That is not to say that climate activists have not had any success, but before anyone gets carried away, the Green Party must keep up its momentum when it does eventually come up against a strong and focussed Labour Party.

If that happens, which it may, that really will be a sign that the British public are warming to the environment.  

Image by European Parliament via Flickr