Are Manchester United and Manchester City responsible for the underperformance of Marcus Rashford and Jack Grealish?
By Wesley Flack
Marcus Rashford’s senior career at Manchester United began in spectacular fashion. At just eighteen, he scored twice on his first-team, and European debut, against Midtjylland in the Europa League in February 2016, before repeating the feat on his Premier League debut against Arsenal three days later. He soon added goals on his first appearance in the Manchester derby, the EFL Cup, and the Champions League.
In May of the same year, he marked his England debut with a goal, becoming, at the time, the Three Lions’ youngest player to score on his first senior international appearance (since overtaken by Myles Lewis-Skelly). This meteoric rise inevitably drew immense attention: fans and media alike hailed him as a future superstar, destined to lead both club and country. The weight of these expectations, however, were bound to have a dangerous effect.
Jack Grealish had a rise to prominence that was steadier than Rashford’s, yet no less remarkable. At just 23, he was named captain of his boyhood club, Aston Villa, and led them to promotion in the 2018-19 season. Following this, in the 2019-20 season, he was fouled 167 times, making him the most-fouled player in a single Premier League campaign ever. Grealish was untouchable. He played with freedom and arrogance that made him a fan favourite not only at Villa Park, but across England, and beyond.
Grealish was untouchable
He was seen as a rare antidote to the increasingly rigid patterns of modern football. Unfortunately, after a record-breaking £100 million transfer to Manchester City, Grealish was contained under Pep Guardiola’s meticulously structured and controlled system. He simply became another cog in a well-oiled machine.
Rashford’s career has been shaped, and at times hindered, by managerial upheaval at Manchester United. Under Louis van Gaal, the manager who first gave him his chance, Rashford thrived. But the arrival of José Mourinho brought a different philosophy: winning was what mattered, not good football. For a young player, this shift in priorities could have limited his development. Since his Hollywood start at United, Rashford continued to show flashes of the brilliance that once lit up Old Trafford, but he struggled to find the consistency required to establish himself among the game’s elite.
For both Rashford and Grealish, the media have created an insurmountable pressure to perform, extending their gaze well beyond the pitch. During COVID, Rashford was widely praised for his political activism in urging the British government to extend free school meals. Yet in bridging the gap between football and politics, he also opened himself up to intensified scrutiny, with his actions, both on and off the pitch, dissected in the public eye.
For both Rashford and Grealish, the media have created an insurmountable pressure to perform…
Grealish, by contrast, was fined after breaching government guidelines during the same period. The contrast between the two is not a matter of right versus wrong, as both have had their fair share of both praise and criticism since, but rather an illustration of how once a player enters the public spotlight, they become trapped within it, and an escape from constant attention proves impossible. Over recent years, both have repeatedly been plagued by a disproportionate number of headlines questioning their attitude.
Recently, both players have sought fresh starts away from Manchester through loan moves. Grealish joined Everton, a transfer some fans interpreted as the beginning of a downward trajectory, echoing Wayne Rooney’s late-career return in 2017–18 or James Rodríguez’s brief spell in 2020–21. Yet Grealish has made an immediate impact: four assists in his first two matches. This equals his goal contributions from his last two seasons at City. Early signs suggest that he thrives more naturally at a mid-table club, where his flair makes fans hold their breath and hope.
Rashford, meanwhile, went to Aston Villa on loan last season, a spell he described to Gary Lineker and Micah Richards as “what he needed on a personal level,” and which most would concur was fairly successful. His performances there opened the door to a move to Barcelona, where his pace and directness aligned neatly with Hansi Flick’s aggressive high line.
Rashford and Grealish, of course, must take responsibility for their own performances. They are professionals earning a lot of money to do a job. Yet, their stories reveal how skewed expectations from fans and media, combined with inevitable pressures of representing clubs of immense stature, shape careers in ways that cannot be ignored. Their success elsewhere suggests that talent alone is never enough without the right environment to nurture it.
Image Credit: Voltmetro via Wikimedia Commons

