Are ‘Green Tories’ a thing of the past?
By Alex Everest-House
It is perhaps the swiftest turnaround in the policy direction of one government to the next on climate. The comments made by Graham Stuart, the new Climate Minister, that granting over 100 new licences to drill for oil in the North Sea is “good for the environment” have again stirred up questions over just how green Liz Truss’s new government will be, and how it will keep to the UK’s goal of reaching Net Zero by 2050. Even more so, it has enraged the ‘green’ wing of the Conservative Party, who was responsible for the moratorium on fracking from Johnson’s government in 2019. Is encouraging the production of even more fossil fuels really a sensible direction, and will it silence the Conservative MPs opposed to it?
As much as Stuart’s comments seem implausible, they are founded in truth: he claimed during his inaugural appearance at the Environmental Audit Committee that producing oil and gas domestically is more environmentally friendly than importing it from overseas, and therefore should be encouraged to reduce emissions and help reach the net zero goal. The Oil and Gas Authority (OGA) indeed found in a report in 2020 that imported gas is on average responsible for more than double the emissions of gas extracted in the UK. Yet, whilst this is true, it ignores the context of much of the UK’s imports; according to the same OGA report, pipeline imports from Norway particularly produce 18% fewer carbon emissions than domestic production, and as such critics argue it makes little sense to prop up a supply chain that only furthers the UK from its climate goals. There is, however, an argument for jobs; many Conservative MPs remember the miners’ strikes of the 1980s and do not want to see such levels of unemployment again amongst drill workers through the closure of oil rigs – indeed, Stuart emphasised that the new licences in the North Sea would be “good for jobs”. Even if this were true, opponents argue that it cannot be an excuse for increased emissions, especially only a year after the UK chaired the COP26 climate conference, and further that it lacks the economic drive the country so sorely needs as it heads toward recession.
…imported gas is on average responsible for more than double the emissions of gas extracted in the UK.
Labour wish to tackle this lack of economic drive with a revitalisation of how the UK gets its energy – during the September party conference, leader Keir Starmer committed to a goal of making the entire grid net zero by 2030, and Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves promised more than £28bn for a “greener economy”. The split between the two parties is usually fairly well defined, but currently, on climate, it is the starkest it has been for decades; the Conservatives wish to cut back freedoms and funding for many green initiatives, lifting the fracking ban and talking of banning solar farms, whilst Labour push for a cleaner and greener economy. Of course, it is not just Labour who have serious concerns with the plans, with Greenpeace even going as far as suggesting the new drilling could be “unlawful”. Ultimately, they are very difficult to justify when the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) warned more than a year ago in its latest major report that we should treat the climate situation as a “code red for humanity”; drilling for more oil in the North Sea and restarting fracking when the same investment could be made in renewables, creating a new wave of high-tech employment – too many, both within and outside of the Conservative party, this seems simply irresponsible and dangerous. Under the Truss government, it seems that the concerns ‘Green Tories’ have may well be ignored.
The split between the two parties is usually fairly well defined, but currently on climate it is the starkest it has been for decades.
Or will they? Perhaps in the current political climate, it is unsurprising that there has been serious backlash within the parliamentary Conservative party to many of these measures, with even senior cabinet ministers being opposed to parts of the plans; the business secretary Jacob Rees-Mogg is said to be at odds with Truss over the solar farm ban, calling it “unconservative” in private, and some backbench Conservative MPs are supposedly in talks with Labour about voting against legislation to end the fracking moratorium. Given all of this, it seems that green conservatism is not dead in British politics, and that conservative pragmatism will eventually dictate that the environment is one of the most important issues facing the country in its history – just how long it will take Truss to agree with her colleagues is a different matter altogether.
Image: Cuomo Policy Summit via Wikimedia Commons

