Antisemitism: past and present

By Lucy Jameson

Wiley’s bombardment of antisemitic hate speech in July sparked a strong social media response and social media giant, Twitter, permanently banned him for his remarks. Whilst Wiley was justly punished, his comments were left unchecked for far too long, and this begs the question as to whether enough is being done to tackle antisemitism in the present day, particularly within the context of the Covid-19 pandemic. As more people have moved online to communicate, monitoring what is shared on social media sites has become more difficult. Hate speech that would typically be removed swiftly is being left to collect comments, shares and likes for several hours – even days – before action is taken, despite reports being made by other users to make companies aware of such abuse. This article will provide some information about antisemitism more broadly, the history of antisemitism and antisemitism in the modern society.

What is Antisemitism?

The Community Security Trust (CST) is a registered charity that seeks to protect and defend the British Jewish community, assist those who are subjected to antisemitic abuse, promote research into racism, and aid the elimination of antisemitism in particular. CST define antisemitism as “hatred, bigotry, prejudice, or discrimination against Jews.”

The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum (USHMM) definition of antisemitism is as follows, “In 1879, German journalist Wilhelm Marr originated the term antisemitism, denoting the hatred of Jews, and also hatred of various liberal, cosmopolitan, and international political trends of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries often associated with Jews. The trends under attack included equal civil rights, constitutional democracy, free trade, socialism, finance capitalism, and pacifism.”

Antisemitism is still a pernicious problem, and many antisemitic tropes from the past can still be seen today

However, the discrimination, hatred and murder of Jewish people has existed since Biblical times. Since then, the definition has evolved and is used more broadly to encompass all forms of discrimination, hate and prejudice towards Jewish people throughout history and in the present day.

It is important to note that CST also use the spelling “antisemitism” rather than “anti-Semitism”. Using “anti-Semitism” could encourage the promotion of the idea that there is something known as ‘Semitism’, that an individual could be against. By using “antisemitism”, this helps to eliminate any possibilities of inflammatory language.

History of Antisemitism

In the UK

The Jewish community throughout history have faced acts of antisemitism. The CST report, Antisemitic Discourse in Britain, provides a brief overview of the history of persecution that the Jewish community has faced in the British Isles since establishing settlements after 1066.

In March 1190, a mob attacked members of the Jewish community in York, forcing them to take shelter in York castle. The mob demanded that the Jews should convert to Christianity. Upon realising they were unable to escape, some of the Jews killed themselves. Those that survived went to the gates of the castle, promising to convert to Christianity. Despite this, the mob murdered them. About 150 Jewish people died altogether. This attack was not anomalous and there were several others, including in London in 1189 when leaders of Jewish communities attended the coronation of King Richard I and were attacked by the crowd. 

There has been a large influx of antisemitic abuse due to the Covid-19 pandemic

In 1275, King Edward I issued a law called the Statute of the Jewry, placing restrictions on Jewish life. Historians believe that the King was attempting to force them to convert to Christianity. In 1290 he issued the Edict of Expulsion, ordering all Jews to leave England within 105 days. They were only able to return in 1656 when Oliver Cromwell allowed them to create a Jewish community in London.

The Black Death

In the period of 1348-50, there was a large outbreak of the Black Death, which drove across Europe, killing a third of the continent’s population and around half the population in England. In many areas of Europe, Jewish people were blamed for the outbreak. People believed that Jewish people had poisoned the wells that people drank from. Despite Pope Clement VI saying that blaming Jewish people was completely unreasonable, he was ignored. As a consequence of the accusations, there were massacres of Jewish people in France, Spain and Germany, with the worst massacre taking place in Strasbourg. The Black Death had not even arrived in Strasbourg when, on 14th February 1349, hundreds of Jewish people were burned to death. Despite the city council’s best efforts to protect them, the council leaders were forced out of power by the mob which, several days later, went on to murder. This is a clear and early example of dehumanisation towards Jewish people.

Rome Ghetto

Pope Paul IV created a ghetto in Rome in 1555. The ghetto was created in a poor part of the city, and Jewish people were forced to live here. If Jews were to leave the walls of the ghetto, they had to wear distinctive markings (which were yellow). They were not allowed to leave at night, and were locked in. Furthermore, the Jewish community had to pay a tax to have permission to stay living in the ghetto. On the Jewish Sabbath, which was every Saturday, Jews were forced to listen to Christian sermons. The creation of the ghetto was somewhat a form of punishment, as at this time it was a common Christian belief that God punished Jews because they were responsible for the death of Jesus. Pope Paul hoped that the Jewish community would convert to Christianity. There were ghettos in several parts of Italy, but the Rome ghetto was in operation for the longest and was finally abolished in 1870 when Italy took control of Rome from the pope.

Between January and June, CST recorded the third highest number of antisemitic incidents in the UK on record

The Dreyfus affair

An incident that reflects just how widespread antisemitism was in France was the Dreyfus affair. French army captain, Alfred Dreyfus, was arrested in 1894 after being accused of spying on Germany. However, he was innocent. It was actually Ferdinand Walsin Esterhazy who was spying, but the army did not want to say they had made an error. Despite the injustice in the situation, Dreyfus was found guilty, and given a life sentence, while Esterhazy walked free. Heavy dispute and divide ensued in France as a result of the sentencing. Many intellectuals supported Dreyfus, yet many others believed supporting Dreyfus’ release would compromise France’s security. This led to antisemitic riots in several cities. It took until 1906 to declare Dreyfus innocent: 12 years after his arrest. This was not an easy success. In 1899, the Supreme Court overturned the original verdict, but he was found guilty again in a new military trial. His eventual pardon by the government meant he was still deemed guilty, until his name was cleared in 1906.

The Beilis case

A 13 year-old boy, Andrei Yushchinsky, was murdered in Kiev in 1911. Menachem Mendel Beilis, a Jewish man, was arrested and put on trial in September 1913, even though he had evidence to prove he was innocent, as he was at work. The investigating officer, Nikolai Krasovsky, was told he needed to falsify evidence, and was sacked from his job because he refused to do so. Thankfully, the jury found Beilis not guilty, as the case against him was so poor. The attempt to frame Beilis for the murder of Yushchinsky, when it was in fact the work of a criminal gang, is an example of a modern blood libel. A blood libel is a false accusation that Jewish people murdered Christian children as part of their religious customs. These accusations had been common in the medieval period, particularly in Europe. However, some people still held these beliefs in the 20th century. An additional cause in the Beilis case were the actions of Tsar Nicholas II, who attempted to blame the Jewish community for Russia’s issues, and went as far as supporting attacks on them.

The Holocaust

In the 20th century, the Nazis and their collaborators organised the systematic mass murder of approximately six million Jewish people. Other minority groups were also victims of Nazi persecution, but the Nazis and their collaborators attempted the complete destruction of the Jewish people. The Holocaust did not start with murder. It started with words, anti-Jewish laws and ghettoization, in the early 1930s.

Covid-19 has not stopped the Holocaust Educational Trust’s outreach programme, which has continued online

Whilst Jewish people today have many more rights and liberties in the UK and elsewhere, antisemitism is still a pernicious problem in society, and many antisemitic tropes from the past can still be seen today. Historically, antisemitism has been based on ideas of religion, and during the rise of Nazism, antisemitism focused upon racial hatred. During the current contemporary period, antisemitism has a particular focus on politics and nation states.

Antisemitism Today

In the Antisemitic Discourse in Britain report, CST stated that “there is an antisemitic form of anti-Zionism that treats Zionism as a global, malevolent conspiracy, much as antisemites have portrayed Jews in the past.” In a Parliamentary Committee report, CST and the Jewish Leadership Council (JLC) defined Zionism as “an ideological belief in the authenticity of Jewish peoplehood and that the Jewish people have the right to a state.” CST noted that criticism of Israel or Zionism is not necessarily antisemitic in the first instance, but there is a large risk of it becoming so when typical antisemitic themes are then applied. CST also pointed out that this frequently occurs when the words Israeli or Zionist are used to replace the word Jew. For example, the term “Zionist” is regularly used against people who speak out against antisemitism.

Currently, there has been a large influx of antisemitic abuse due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Global events that result in political, social and economic volatility often cause an increase in antisemitism, as people seek to blame someone, or something, for their misfortune. This links into Jewish people being referred to as the “other”, as has been the case in the past. The need to connect with people over social media has enabled the spread of intolerant and hateful conspiracy theories and disgustingly malicious messages across the globe.

Social media has enabled the spread of intolerant and hateful conspiracy theories and malicious messages across the globe

Many of these examples include blaming Jewish people for the spread of diseases and the plague. Some examples of antisemitism CST have recorded recently have included posts that state Covid-19 is a Jewish conspiracy hoax; that Covid-19 does exist, but is still a Jewish conspiracy, because it has been intentionally created by Jewish people to deliberately cause harm. Antisemitic discourse has also focused on referring to Covid-19 as the ‘Jew Flu’. The intention of this language is to suggest that Jewish people are behind the virus, or that they are the most common spreaders of it. Abhorrent social media posts have been shared celebrating the death tolls of Jewish people and encouraging people to spread the ‘Holocough’. Many of these dangerous comments are being shared on sites such as 4chan and Gab, which provide a space for those with extremist views to share ideas. Having these comments posted on these websites is a cause for concern: it is known that people such as Robert Bowers, who murdered 11 people at a synagogue in Pittsburgh in 2018, use these sites to share their intentions and document attacks.

This year, between January and June, CST recorded the third highest number of antisemitic incidents in the UK on record. Antisemitism is still a huge problem in the UK, and across the world. More needs to be done to challenge antisemitism, particularly on social media sites, where antisemitic hate can spread far and wide at a rapid pace. Although progress has been made in addressing and removing antisemitism on these sites, there is still a long way to go.

However, hope is not lost. Ambassadors and staff at the Holocaust Educational Trust work tirelessly all year round to promote Holocaust remembrance, and encourage others to actively take part in spreading awareness. The work of those at the Trust includes providing educational resources, delivering teacher training and liaising with public bodies such as the media and Parliament to help prevent the spread of misinformation within society. Regional Ambassadors work to deliver projects in their local areas, coming up with creative and new ways to promote Holocaust remembrance and encourage their communities to actively participate in learning about the Holocaust and its contemporary relevance. Additionally, the Trust facilitate for Ambassadors to work together with Holocaust survivors, to share their testimonies with the wider public and the younger generations, something which is a powerful, humbling, and moving experience. Covid-19 has not stopped the Trust’s outreach programme, which has continued online, with the survivors learning how to use platforms such as Zoom to ensure their stories are still heard.

Image: Amit Lahav via Unsplash