Another division in the left

By Rafi Glass

Had the December 2019 General Election been held in June, YouGov would have projected a Brexit Party triumph. A few months later, Farage’s firebrands ended up taking zero seats. If the 1983 General Election had been held the year prior, the SDP-Liberal alliance similarly would have been expecting a Downing Street welcome. In June of the following year, the party won 23 seats. It is a widely-accepted political maxim that alternative parties rarely succeed. 

Gina Miller, the former investment manager cum anti-Brexit campaigner, disagrees. Miller’s new party, ‘True and Fair’, aims to “hold the government to account” and move beyond the “politics of incompetence”. With Boris Johnson’s Conservatives hampered by a fuel and energy crisis, poor handling of the Covid-19 pandemic, a Christmas-threatening HGV driver shortage, and bereft of much ministerial talent, perhaps now is the time for any and all opposition to stick the knives in. 

It seems, however, that Miller’s party has as much chance of effecting change as Boris Johnson has of being reincarnated as an olive or decapitated by a frisbee. Whilst True and Fair are yet to publish a manifesto, one can assume that the party will lean left, with perhaps a focus on rejoining the EU. It is improbable that the electorate behind Johnson’s 2019 routing will suddenly switch allegiance from John Redwood to Rory Stewart and send Miller into parliament. 

It is Keir Starmer’s Labour Party, a fragmented crew of infighting sloganeers, who stand to lose the most

It is Keir Starmer’s Labour Party, a fragmented crew of infighting sloganeers, who stand to lose the most. Labour hits the news more for Rayner’s ranting, Abbott’s tweets and McDonald’s posturing, than for any concrete policy proposals. Despite Starmer’s best efforts, however, it will not be forgotten that he orchestrated Labour’s disastrous 2019 Brexit policy. Starmer, and by association his Labour Party, is identified with EU-philia, and those who vote for him are likely to agree with Miller. 

It must of course be noted, however, that the Labour Party is not simply an embodiment of Starmer-ism. His 2019 Brexit policy was not representative of Labour in its entirety, even if the party is now tarnished and identified by it. It evolved from ambiguity to something that sought to pursue a nuanced stance (supporting the idea of a deal followed by an election followed by a referendum on the deal – how did the electorate struggle to understand this!) but ultimately it never made a clear pitch for the Remain vote. At the core of this ambiguity was a genuine division within the party over ideological preference and political strategy; 61% of Labour MPs represented constituencies that had a majority leave vote in 2016, but 68% of Labour voters supported Remain. This could perhaps mean that True and Fair aligns less with Labour than it immediately seems, posing less of a political threat. 

So is Miller’s project therefore simply an act of ideological self-harm? It still appears so. True and Fair, if it successfully registers with the Electoral Commission and manages to attract any votes, will surely siphon support only from Labour. In 1983, Labour lost 9.4 points and the Liberal-SDP Alliance gained 11.9. It is impossible to suggest that all those millions of erstwhile 1979 Labour voters surged to the SDP, but the intervention of a new party undoubtedly played a role in Thatcher’s landslide. One must adhere to Santayana’s aphorism here: “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it”. If Miller seeks to hold the government to account, one may wonder how detracting from the parliamentary opposition pursues this aim. 

The strategy for any political leader who wants to dethrone and usurp Johnson should be to stand resolutely behind Starmer

The 2021 London Mayoral elections attracted 20 competing parties and has perhaps inaugurated a period of individual political projects. Gina Miller could be about to join the ranks of Kam Balayev, Valerie Brown, Piers Corbyn, Laurence Fox, Richard Hewison, Steve Kelleher, David Kurten, Farah London, Nims Obunge and Brian Rose; all of whom lost their deposit in pursuit of independent political success. Dominic Cummings is unlikely to be receiving a panicked call from Johnson. 

The strategy for any political leader who wants to dethrone and usurp Johnson should be to stand resolutely behind Starmer. The recent Labour Party conference, replete with some much-needed personality and oomph, has provided a welcome bounce for the struggling leader. Decisively moving the party back to the political centre, and lambasting the legacy of perennial activist Jeremy Corbyn, is the only way for Starmer to stand any chance of becoming prime minister, and he seems to recognise this, even if the vast majority of the electorate could not tell you anything he stands for. 

Delusion’s time in the sun must surely have come and gone at some point between Nigel Farage’s seventh attempt at sitting for Parliament and former Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson’s claim that she is “a candidate to be prime minister”. If Miller does achieve any success with True and Fair (and it is worth remembering that despite successful legal challenges, Miller’s political history is pockmarked with the failed Best for Britain – which sought to continue the UK’s membership of the EU – and Remain United campaigns), it will only be to the detriment of Starmer. Ultimately, the Conservatives will be toasting to Miller’s triumph.

Image: Journo Resources via Flickr

Support Palatinate