Andrew Motion's book that changed Larkin's reputation

Andrew Motion’s 1993 biography of Philip Larkin caused a stir in literary circles for its unflinching exploration of the less savory aspects of the poet-librarian’s life. But nearly 25 years after Larkin’s death, and more than fifteen years since the publication of A Writer’s Life, does Motion’s biography still have the same impact?

The book’s sympathetic depiction of this confusing figure is perhaps its most lasting accomplishment – stemming partly from the acute self-consciousness of writing that both Motion and Larkin have experienced. The Hermit of Hull, as Larkin was known, underwent periods of self-loathing that were the result of his inability to write well. Larkin once declared himself incapable “of becoming an artist. I am filled with waves of self-disgust and doubt…I know what shit is, and won’t write it; on the other hand, I can’t write anything else”. More interesting was Motion’s comic revelation to the Durham University English Society that his friendship with Larkin at Hull, where Motion first lectured, left him too terrified to write his own poetry. This kind of understanding with his subject makes for a compelling biography.

But the connection between the two extends beyond literature. Motion’s portrayal of the more unpleasant details of Larkin’s life is controversial – but also empathetic and sensitive. Celebrated as one of the greatest poets of his century, in private Larkin espoused xenophobic beliefs, had a passion for pornography, and caused great pain in his love affairs – details fans of his poetry might find hard to stomach. Motion, however, elucidates without aggressive explanation. Larkin’s xenophobia, for instance, is shown to be a consequence of childhood holidays to Germany with his father who had a soft spot for fascism. Ultimately, though, Motion realizes that the thought of high windows remains a powerfully poetic image with or without biographical trivia.

Another striking feature of the biography is its portrayal of Larkin as a master of deception, who often shrouds true feelings in evasive and circumlocutory writing. His fears about Larkin at Sixty, a collection of essays by friends and critics, were concealed by his trademark humour. On first seeing a copy of the book, Larkin wrote: “I like the jacket…though it reminds me not so much of Reynolds Stone [the engraver] as his lesser-known but equally talented brother Tomb”. On the surface a light-hearted quip – but the language of mortality betrays his terror that Larkin at Sixty would mark the end of his writing career, and the countdown to death. It is this manner of writing which leads Motion to the conclusion that reading anything by Larkin is like being shown “round the rooms of his mind without opening any secret compartments”. Motion’s ability to open these compartments, to see through the smoke and mirrors and get to the heart of his subject, ensures his biography still has the impact it did in 1993. In his exploration of this extraordinary writer’s life, Motion is very much the less deceived.