Andrew Boff and the crackdown on dissent
By Phoebe Case
In 1968, Enoch Powell’s ‘Rivers of Blood’ speech was the hallmark of bigotry and xenophobic attitudes in British Politics. The same sentiment that at the time attempted to prevent the immigration of people such as Priti Patel, Suella Braverman, and Rishi Sunak is now being promoted by these martyrs of Thatcherite Conservatism. The Conservative Party in Britain is in crisis as it descends further into the chaos of right-wing politics. They are a party with a loose grip on reality but an ever-looser grip on respect from and control over the country. The party is now more similar to the authoritarian Republican Party in the United States than the centre-right party that had the sense to expel Enoch Powell from his role in the Shadow Cabinet after his divisive speech.
The growing intolerance within the Conservative Party was highlighted by the expulsion of Andrew Boff from the Conservative Party Conference in Manchester in early October. Andrew Boff is an openly gay Conservative Party member and Chair of the London Assembly who vocally expressed his distaste towards Braverman’s comments on trans people. In her speech, Braverman claimed that “gender ideology” as well as “wokeness” and “anti-British history” had permeated the workplace and wider culture and is presented to people like “motherhood” and “apple pie”. Andrew Boff, formerly a loyal Conservative, was heard vocally disagreeing and saying “gender ideology doesn’t exist” before being escorted out by security.
If a difference of opinion can’t exist within the Conservative Party and the Government itself, then how can they be trusted to run a country that is largely tolerant, welcoming, and respectful? This is the party that shouts ‘free speech’ at every given opportunity, yet silences their own members. Although Braverman took to X (formerly Twitter) and stated that “Andrew Boff’s heckles were silly, but I think he should be forgiven and let back into conference”, she completely ignores any valid criticism from Boff and reduces it to a silly heckle. Is this the type of response we have come to accept from our government?
This is the party that shouts ‘free speech’ at every given opportunity, yet silences their own members
This government lacks the competence to even respond properly to those who challenge them. During the May government, where her cabinet had a diverse range of Tory opinions, ideas and criticisms were listened to and not invalidated. Even though this allowed for many a failed Brexit deal, it is a positive reflection on the tolerance of opinion that used to be accepted in the Conservative Party. How has British politics become so dire that one could reminisce on the politics of 2017?
The problem I have with politicians trying to ignite culture wars, and talk about what cultural issues matter to the British people, is that they fundamentally don’t know. The government are out of touch with the people; they do not live within British society, they attempt to live above it. When thinking about any politician, one must ask what makes them qualified to comment on a subject, especially with such subjective issues like immigration. When thinking about Braverman, one must ask, ‘how many trans people does she personally know?’ How does ‘anti-wokeness’ and ‘gender ideology’ affect her life personally? Or do Braverman and her colleagues use matters like the existence of trans people and immigration to cover the cracks of their failed thirteen years in power?
Instead of caring about our strained healthcare system, our crumbling schools, our lack of technological innovation pursues divisiveness, they stoke culture wars
Instead of caring about our strained healthcare system, our crumbling schools, our lack of technological innovation pursues divisiveness, they stoke culture wars. This is a Conservative Party that has fallen into a chasm of ‘anti’; they will stand against anything that is seemingly ‘woke’ and will try their best to divide and conquer the country by igniting culture wars over trans rights and issues surrounding immigration to distract from their continuing ineptitude.
A tolerant society is a hard thing to come by and takes decades to develop. It would be wrong to argue that Britain is the most tolerant place on Earth, but it seems as if this government is unwilling to let the country thrive and pursue tolerance. The Conservative government seem more comfortable pursuing Powell’s xenophobia of the late 1960s, which should make the people of Britain uncomfortable with the fact that these are the people in power. This Conservative government is the hallmark of bigotry in Britain in 2023 and they will continue to be as long as they get the chance.
Image: ukhouseoflords via Wikimedia Commons
