Analysis: Why are staff taking industrial action, and what have they achieved so far?

By Laetitia Eichinger

The impact of the longstanding industrial dispute between university employers and staff continues to be felt at universities across the country. 

While it does not seem that an immediate end to industrial action is in sight, progress towards the UCU’s aims has been made since the first walkouts in 2018. The strikes are the product of two separate disputes. 

The first concerns proposed changes to the Universities Superannuation Scheme (USS) – the pension scheme for many employees in higher education – which the UCU argued will “drastically” reduce the level of members’ guaranteed retirement income.

The second – dubbed the ‘four fights’ or ‘UCU rising’ dispute – arose over concerns around pay, equality, staff workload, and casualisation. The UCU has estimated that, since 2009, the value of pay in higher education has fallen by approximately 25% with inflation, and that around one-third of all academic staff are employed on fixed-term contracts. 

While the ‘four fights’ dispute is ongoing, the pensions dispute recently culminated in a “historic victory”. On 17th April, the UCU announced that members had overwhelmingly voted to move forward with pension proposals agreed with employers, which included commitments to prioritise the restoration of retirement benefits. The planned marking and assessment boycott was therefore withdrawn at universities, which were only involved in the pensions dispute.

While strikes related to the ‘four fights’ dispute are likely to continue for the foreseeable future, recent talks with trade unions did lead to some changes in university policy.

However, in the ‘four fights’ dispute, members voted by 56% to reject the proposals agreed by employers, which have so far included a pay increase of between 5% and 8% from August 2023. This rejection led to the marking boycott, which ran from 20th April to 6th September. The UCU currently maintains that this pay increase offer is well below inflation, that it “does nothing for years of pay degradation”, and that there were no further offers made on the issues of casualisation, workload, and equality.

While strikes related to the ‘four fights’ dispute are likely to continue for the foreseeable future, recent talks with trade unions did lead to some change in university policy. 

Durham has agreed to seek accreditation from the Living Wage Foundation, which would require all Durham employees to receive at least the real living wage (currently £10.90 p/hour), offer staff more visa support, and increase pay for assistant professors.

The University already bases most wages on the Living Wage’s benchmark, however, without accreditation, they are not obliged to do so. Casual staff, such as student ambassadors and students who work for a college, have previously not been on Durham’s pay scale; in some cases, their pay has been below the Living Wage rate.

In information sent to staff, Durham said that they will be seeking “accreditation as soon as possible, with the implementation of the Real Living Wage from the next annual update in May 2024”.

A spokesperson for Durham UCU told Palatinate, “The Marking Boycott was necessary due to the unwillingness of university managers to negotiate over pay and conditions. Locally, UCU, the other campus unions and the SU have been calling for the university to commit to the Real Living Wage for a very long time.

“The strength shown by UCU members in the marking boycott is a key reason why management has finally shifted. Students and other low-paid staff across the university will benefit from the RLW in future and it is the industrial action by UCU members this year that has finally forced management to act.”

The email to staff, announcing the new package of measures, was signed by the campus leaders of Unison, GMB, Unite, and Durham’s Vice Chancellor Karen O’Brien.

The email said, “While we will be able to implement some of the measures quickly, other issues are more complex and will take time to work through. We will work jointly with our trade union colleagues in developing the details of these proposals.

“We recognise that there is much that we can achieve together, and this is an important first step in a phased programme of work. We will jointly continue our constructive dialogue, and commit to further negotiations on issues of local importance identified by the trade unions. This will include the issues raised in a local claim by DUCU.”

Image: Thomas Tomlinson