An Unhappy Election in Burundi
By Ollie Geffen
In 2018 the World Happiness Report ranked Burundi as the least happy nation on the planet. This unhappy land lies by the great lakes, landlocked between Rwanda, the DRC, Uganda and Tanzania. Politics in the region have been dominated by clashes between the Tutsi and Hutu tribes, a conflict which at its most bleak led to the Rwandan genocide in 1994. The previous year Burundi elected its first Hutu leader, Melchior Ndadye, only for him to be assassinated within months by Tutsi extremists. This led to a civil war claiming 300,000 lives, ending only in 2005 with the election of the leader of the Hutu rebel group CNDD-FDD Pierre Nkurunziza.
Nkurunziza led with reasonable authority for two terms, and he had some, albeit limited success, including the establishment of free healthcare for mothers and children, as well as providing free primary education. In 2015, he won a third term in an election described as a joke by critics, leading to riots and violence which killed thousands of protestors. The result of this political turmoil was an increase in state power and a clamp down on free speech and media. The dangers of Nkurunziza’s rule have recently been seen in his reaction to Covid-19: as well as expelling four officials from the WHO, he claimed national exceptionalism stating that Burundi would be unaffected by the pandemic because “it is a country that has put God first”. It therefore came as some surprise when Nkurunziza announced that he would step down at the end of his third term despite having access to a fourth.
The highly politicised courts in Burundi ruled that there had been a fair election, despite strong evidence of ballot stuffing and the use of unofficial electoral registers.
May 20th was the date set for the election of Nkurunziza’s replacement, pitting the CNDD-FDD successor Evariste Ndayishimiye against the head of the National Freedom Council (CNL) Agathon Rwasa. With the election date set, a particularly intense period of violence and oppression ensued. On May 11th two people were killed in a grenade attack at a bar belonging to the Imbonerakure, the violent youth league of the CNDD-FDD, whilst the CNL have themselves claimed to be subjected to 600 politically motivated arrests. External election monitors were told by the CNDD-FDD that they would have to isolate for 14 days after entering Burundi meaning they could not provide the necessary checks and balances for an election in Burundi. On election day itself all social media apps were taken offline. This was anything but a fair and democratic election.
Ndayishimiye won with 69% of the vote and predictably Rwasa immediately filed a complaint to Burundi’s courts claiming fraud. The highly politicised courts in Burundi ruled that there had been a fair election, despite strong evidence of ballot stuffing and the use of unofficial electoral registers. Rwasa is now likely to take the case to the East African Court of Justice in Tanzania, but will face a huge domestic challenge regardless of the result.
The future of Burundi is uncertain. This was an election in which neither of the leaders were overwhelmingly palatable. Rwasa formerly led the National Liberation Forces, a group which enlisted child soldiers and inflicted grave harm to women and children. Ndayishimiye, meanwhile, inherits a tough political situation. He has a military background and so has the support of his generals yet is inheriting a state in which oppression is the norm. He also has to balance his own interests with that of Nkurunziza who has created for himself the position of Supreme Guide. Ndayishimiye will be legally obliged to consult Nkurunziza on all future policy.
The hope for Burundians is that Ndayishimiye inherits a seven-year term which might lead to long-term thinking and policies. Over the past year he has consulted African Union and UN leaders which is an encouraging sign, but the success of Ndayishimiye ultimately rests on whether he relaxes oppression in his regime: only then might Burundi begin to become a happy country.
Image: Paul Kagame via Flickr
