An Unhappy Crisis Coalition

By Martha Muir

For many world leaders, Covid-19 has been an unwelcome distraction. But for Bibi ‘the magician’ Netanyahu, crisis is opportunity. On April 20th Netanyahu and his rival Benny Gantz agreed to form a national unity government, marking a welcome end to a year-long crisis in which Netanyahu’s right-wing faction and Gantz’s centrist alliance were virtually neck and neck, and unable to form a governing coalition. Predicting the collapse of Israel’s longest-serving prime minister has become a clichéd nugget of political wisdom amongst commentators around election time. But the deal (or concession) struck allows him to remain in the job for the next 18 months, after which Gantz will take over. 

Even under lockdown, Netanyahu’s opponents have expressed their displeasure at his revival. Weekly socially-distanced protests and eight petitions to the high court have urged the judiciary to rule Netanyahu is ineligible to form a government, on account of corruption charges that have dogged him since 2016. It is argued that as a caretaker leader he is not entitled to protection under a law which states that prime ministers are not obliged to step down when charged with a crime. Adding to the solution’s complexity is that the agreement will require Israel’s constitutional Basic Laws to be amended, to allow for the rotation to occur. 

Notwithstanding the deal’s legality, 56% of Israelis are right to favour the deal. Coronavirus has left many unemployed in a country with an already crippling cost of living. An approaching recession needs a functional government to manage it. 

If the deal is blocked, Israel will go to the polls for the fourth time, and the supreme court will face the wrath of an already hostile political right, which has pressed for its powers to be curtailed in favour of the Knesset’s elected lawmakers. The Likud energy minister Yuval Steinitz said the court ruling against Netanyahu would be an “an unprecedented attack on Israeli democracy”, and even the Blue and White alliance’s lawyers have stated that the deal should be implemented unhindered. 

An approaching recession needs a functional government to manage it

For his part in ushering Netanyahu back into office, Gantz has been accused of surrendering to and abetting the man he branded untrustworthy on the campaign trail. But Gantz has made room for himself between a rock and a hard place. Although Gantz had the support of a majority of Knesset members to be prime minister, he was unable to form a coalition due to insurmountable rifts in his base. In September the Joint Arab List alliance broke with tradition by endorsing a Jewish, explicitly Zionist, candidate. However, the prospect of Gantz forming a minority government with the support of the Arab parties led to defections within his own bloc.

In accepting the deal he has gained control over the defence, foreign affairs and justice ministries. This will give Gantz the power to slow the march towards the annexation of the West Bank, and ensure that Netanyahu’s trial proceeds in May.

Despite his reputation outside Israel, over his 14 years in office, Netanyahu has built a mythos around himself as being indispensable to Israel’s national security and world standing. Gantz cannot hope to replicate this in under two years. He risks at worst losing another election, and at best being mathematically constrained during coalition talks. From within the government, he can stay Netanyahu’s more right-leaning designs, and claim the moral high ground for compromising. They might also thank him for sparing them from a fourth election.

Image: GovPhilMurphy via CreativeCommons