An uneasy relationship with peace and violence
During BBC Question Time on the 26th January, discussion turned to whether female soldiers should take part in front-line combat in the armed forces. There are arguments against this which deserve consideration, but Charles Moore of the Daily Telegraph had an interesting one: ‘[it wouldn’t be] an advance in human civilisation if women abandoned their traditional association with peace and started killing people as men do.’
This made me ask myself a few questions. Are women really associated with peace? Who associates them with peace? And is this association a good thing?
It is true that the average female is less likely to be physically violent than the average male, and that this difference is observable from childhood (though many of us, myself included, used to enjoy taking part in the rough and tumble of the playground, showing that this is not a universal rule). However, absence of physical violence does not necessarily equal ‘peace,’ in the sense of a tranquil and positive relationship between groups.
A scene from Rob Marshall’s 2005 film ‘Memoirs of a Geisha’ comes to mind. At a tea party, the heroine and her rival are competing for the attentions of the wealthy men on whom their livelihoods depend. The men chuckle as the two geisha subtly undercut one another, charmed and amused by the witty repartee and the fact that these beautiful women are squabbling over them. Later, in the house they share, the heroine’s rival grabs her by the hair, slaps her face, and whispers, ‘I will destroy you.’
The physical violence may be an extreme for women, but the poisonous feelings that underlie it are all too familiar to most of us. Women, then, it seems, are hardly peaceful. The saying ‘if women ruled the world, there would be no wars, just a bunch of jealous countries not speaking to each other’ strikes me as more accurate. So, where did this ‘traditional association with peace’ come from? Most likely it was an association invented by men.
Until comparatively recently, women’s role in life was to make themselves pleasing companions to the men they supported. When the men came home from killing people, which Charles Moore seems to think of as their typical role, the women would be on their best behaviour. The most that happened in front of a male audience would be some subtle undercutting; the hair-pulling and face-slapping happened in private. Add to that the fact that for most of history women have not had the power or responsibility to start wars, and you have the origin of women’s traditional association with peace. This association is, in fact, an obvious piece of pedestalisation. It endows women with a shining virtue, without actually giving them the opportunity to decide for themselves whether it is a virtue they aspire towards.
Elsewhere, Moore comments on the irony of left-wing young women, who would normally be against war and violence, demanding the right to kill. It does not seem to occur to him that this irony cuts both ways: if he believes that having front-line soldiers who are willing to fight is a good thing, then why is he suddenly arguing that it is better to not fight and be associated with peace? If this association with peace is really a privilege, and not a fetter, then why don’t men start protesting against the dismissive ‘as men do’ that relegates them to the role of killers, and start demand to be associated with peace too?
Maybe they should. Peace is, after all, better than war. But designating one group, women, to strive for peace while the rest of us carry on fighting isn’t going to get us anywhere. Men and women need to be equally empowered to fight, and then they will be empowered to choose, freely and therefore sincerely, to fight for peace.

