An eye for an eye, a life for a life?
Content warning: this article contains discussion of rape and violence.
By Sofia Virgos
In an interview with The Spectator, Lee Anderson, the new Deputy Chairman of the Conservative Party, publicly stated his support for bringing back the death penalty. His brazen assertion that “nobody has ever committed a crime after being executed” has sparked widespread political debate. One cannot help but wonder whether this is merely an individual’s opinion, a whole party’s position – even if current Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has pronounced himself against it – or, even, a foreboding glimpse into the future of the British Isles. It would not be the first country to adopt judicial execution: fifty-five nations across the globe still use capital punishment, including two major democratic powers: Japan and (27 states across) America. But in the case of the UK, the country cannot reinstate this form of punishment unless it leaves the European Convention on Human Rights.
Moral issues aside, the problem with the death sentence is that once it is executed it is irreversible, and that it is impossible to eliminate the risk of executing an innocent person. In the US alone, over the past 50 years 184 death-row prisoners have been exonerated shortly before being executed, once it was proven that they were not guilty. Be that as it may, the “an eye for an eye” commandment was the traditional form of retribution embraced by nations down the ages – even when, as Gandhi observed, “an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind” – and continues to be in force in over a quarter of the world’s countries. What’s more, in the democratic states where capital punishment is legal, there is a majority of people that support it.
Moral issues aside, the problem with the death sentence is that once it is executed it is irreversible
Japan applies capital punishment in the case of single aggravated murder, multiple murder, and in certain instances of crimes against the state, such as treason, with executions carried out by hanging. In the US, the death sentence is imposed for espionage, murder, treason, and some cases of drug trafficking and attempted murder. The most widely used method of execution is lethal injection, but certain states still use electrocution, lethal gas, hanging, and even death by firing squad. Since both countries are democracies, public opinion is measured through polls. However, the problem with polling is that phrasing can alter results enormously. A question such as, “are you in favour of the death penalty?” is too broad at its core: it fails to take into account factors such as how much proof is needed to implement judicial execution, and what crimes should be subject to such punishment.
Bearing this imprecision in mind, the statistics show that, in democracies where the death sentence is legal, a majority of the population supports it. A poll conducted by the Cabinet Office in Japan in 2019 shows that 80.8% of the population support capital punishment as a necessary measure for some crimes. In the US, a study conducted by the Pew Research Center in 2021 indicates that 60% of Americans favour the death penalty for convicted murderers. But what is the opinion in places where capital punishment is no longer active, like the UK?
Lee Anderson is not the first Tory politician to advocate the death penalty. In 2020 Priti Patel, who served as Home Secretary from 2019 to 2022, stated: “I would actually support the reintroduction of capital punishment to serve as a deterrent, because I do think we do not have enough deterrents in this country for criminals”. Could it be, then, that beyond an individual’s opinion, this is, in fact, the view of the party? Although the death penalty for murder was abolished in the UK in 1969, recent polls carried out by YouGov show that British citizens over the age of 65 are twice as likely to vote for its return than young adults, and that 58% of Conservative voters back its implementation, compared to 23% of Labour supporters. Plainly, there is a strong correlation between political stance and the death penalty, with Conservatives much more likely to support it.
There is a strong correlation between political stance and the death penalty, with Conservatives much more likely to support it
But what about the members of the party itself? Rishi Sunak rebuked Anderson for his declaration and claimed that he was not speaking for him or the government. The Prime Minister might not back Anderson, but other Conservative members such as Brendan Clarke-Smith, Conservative MP for Bassetlaw, do. In fact, Clarke-Smith said that this opinion is more popular than people make it out to be, backing his view with recent poll statistics. Clearly, there is a division of opinion in this matter amongst Tory members.
The popularity of capital punishment in the UK can come as a shock. What would it entail for modern society to adapt the behaviour of doing to criminals what they do to victims, and where would one set its limits? Killing a murderer can be seen as acceptable, but what about raping a rapist? The bigger question is where do society’s moral boundaries and ideas of human rights lie? Bringing the death sentence back in the UK could be seen as a set back in evolution and modernisation. Some might argue that in the US and Japan it is in place, so why not in the UK? The answer could be that these democracies missed the chance to abolish the death penalty when other countries did, and that within an evolved human framework, there are higher moral implications involved when it comes to reinstalling such a violent conviction.
Image: David Woolfall via Wikimedia Commons

