An author and a Duchess: Mantel versus Middleton
Award winning author Hilary Mantel has come under a considerable amount of scrutiny recently, after making a speech that depicted the Duchess of Cambridge, Kate Middleton, in a far from favourable light.
The speech, made at an event organised by the London Review of Books, later posted on their website, has caused outrage. Various journalists have gone to war over the speech, some defending our princess, others backing Mantel’s harsh words.
Whilst it cannot be denied that Hilary could have chosen her words more wisely, it would be unfair to see the article as an ‘attack’ on Kate. In the entire article, which is just fewer than 6,000 words long, Kate’s name is only mentioned eight times. However, when Mantel claims that she sees the Duchess ‘becoming a jointed doll on which certain rags are hung’ and that Kate was ‘selected’ for her role because there was no ‘risk of the emergence of character’ from her, we start to see why offence was caused.
As I mentioned previously, it would be harsh to judge Mantel on these comments alone, as they need to be read in the context of the speech to be fully understood. However, the overriding theme, not just of the speech but of the argument that has ensued, ignores the most basic and important of issues.
Kate may be a princess, a woman and a national figure subject to detailed analysis in every area of her life. But she is also a person. Had it occurred to Hilary Mantel that Kate was not ‘selected’ for a ‘role’? Rather she decided to spend the rest of her life with a man who she loves. Of course, that man is the future king of England and thus Kate does have a role to play in the public eye, but nonetheless, we need to be able to see the simple humanity in this case.
Currently the Duchess is pregnant. Surely we should look at this and be happy for Kate, not because she will gift this country with a new prince or princess, but because she will soon be a mother. The bond between mother and child is a beautiful one and to treat the pregnancy as a national game is certainly wrong. Mantel claims in her speech that the press see Kate’s ‘only point and purpose being to give birth,’ and although some newspapers do act like this is the case, that does not make it right.
A debate has also arisen over whether or not Kate is a good role model for young women. Independent writer Katy Guest wrote an article named ‘Women need mouthy Hilary Mantel not flawless Kate Middleton’. Whilst I do not doubt that Hilary Mantel is an excellent role model to aspiring young writers, this does not mean that Kate has no role to play helping the younger generations; her role will be a different one.
Kate Middleton is only an important figure because Prince William chose to marry her. He did not do this on the basis that he believed she would be a good role model for future generations. One would hope that he did so because he loved her. What does Hilary Mantel think is a better option? That William marries someone who he doesn’t really like but who is a bit ‘mouthy’ and willing to cause a stir? Or perhaps that the Royal family ask Kate to speak her mind more, because she clearly never does so?
It may not have occurred to critics that Kate Middleton is not a plastic doll programmed to reproduce and look like a princess should. Instead she is a beautiful woman who wants to start a family with her husband and a genuinely nice person. I am not a royalist or a huge fan of the Duchess, but it isn’t necessary to be either to see that Kate has done nothing wrong.

