Allister Heath: “Have the ideas first and execute them before anyone else!”

By Arjun Seth

Allister Heath is the editor of The Sunday Telegraph and weekly columnist for the daily paper. Having started off as a curious student who sent articles to The Wall Street Journal “just to see if they would get published”, he has become one of the nation’s most prominent journalists and commentators. 

We meet at The Telegraph’s London office where work is buzzing after Rishi Sunak has just delivered a keynote speech setting out his plans for the year. With a war in Europe, ever-growing domestic crises and new bombshells from Harry and Meghan landing by the hour, I begin by asking Heath how as editor, he manages the demands of the 24-hour news cycle. 

“Well, there is 24 hours news, but it’s not quite a 24-hour news cycle, luckily. Things do happen in the world, and you do cover those. I suppose you now have a longer day. Earlier you used to finish early as everything would go for print and now with online it’s very easy for information to be communicated and stories to emerge. Now we just finish later!”. 

As a columnist, Heath has the unique privilege of writing to readers addressing a topic every week. From chaos in Westminster to the culture wars, there is so much to choose from. 

“My job is to write interesting opinion and commentary on the most important events of the moment for my readers. I write my columns from a particular perspective which I hope is consistent – I try and write them in a particular way and hopefully readers are entertained and informed by them. There are always going to be one or two dominant news stories and I try and peg it to one of those news stories”. 

So, if everyone is trying to address the story of the day, how does Heath ensure no one has pinched his idea? 

“Obviously you have lots of ideas and they vanish because someone writes them first. That is the nature of journalism and happens a lot with Comment writing but mainly happens in news stories. If someone is working on a news story, there is always the danger that someone else gets there first. Being first is a very important part of journalism. Have the ideas first and execute them before anyone else!”.

Printed newspaper circulation has been rapidly falling for as long as I can remember. Throughout most of my life I have read more news stories online than in print. Heath acknowledges this decline – “[at The Telegraph] we are all more focused on building a sustainable digital future. I don’t know whether papers will stop being printed but the era of it being the dominant medium is coming to an end”.

Being first is a very important part of journalism”

This leads us on to how established broadsheets such as The Telegraph are managing competition with Twitter. 

“We compete with Twitter because we have a strong authoritative brand, and we are professional journalists. What we do goes through processes of quality control. That is hugely useful for many readers at a time when social media is littered with rubbish, hysteria and lies. We have seen for years that readers like quality. Even though people can get free information on Twitter and social media, millions of people have started subscribing to online newspapers. I think it’s working. There is no doubt about it. We have massively increased our digital subscribers several-fold. 

“Fundamentally, there is a big market for rigorous journalism and that is growing all the time. People are interested in what proper journalists say, i.e. ones who write for newspapers that live up to a certain editorial standard and that is what people will always want to see. There is no point in engaging with the ridiculous. The decline in newspapers has ended and we are now beginning to see a renaissance in the news industry. I wouldn’t say it is despite social media, but rather because of it”. 

We then move on to trolling and online abuse, a sad consequence of their work for most journalists. Heath is especially concerned about the impact it is having on young people – “It’s disgusting – I hate it. Social media companies need to do much more to stamp out that sort of behaviour and I’m very concerned about how trolls pick on younger, more vulnerable journalists. We need to do more to protect them”. 

I then ask Heath whether it is still possible to have a difference of opinion in the modern age. 

“I think it’s highly possible as 85- 90% of the population can manage it! The problem is that there is a hyper-active elite on Twitter for whom having a disagreement is very difficult. That group of people doesn’t represent our whole country. Many people can agree to disagree and discuss things. You have this minority of ultra-engaged activists who see the world in extreme ways where only their side is moral and right and the other side is immoral and wrong. It is a way of trying to make everyone think the same. That is a very toxic way of looking at the world”. 

Heath is known for writing extensively about how the expansion of the state is responsible for Britain’s recent economic decline. He is keen to stress that as a nation we need to rethink our analysis of our problems.

People are interested in what proper journalists say… there is no point in engaging with the ridiculous”

“It’s not too late to reverse it but I don’t think anyone is prepared to do it. That system doesn’t work, and I just hope that one day there will be an alternative that tries with a new group of people, and it will once again to be possible to discuss these things. The NHS is in deep deep crisis but funding in the NHS has gone up substantially. Front-line staff as measured by hours worked has been going up and up, yet output has been falling and the whole system is in crisis. I understand why people think those sorts of mechanisms are the best way to ensure healthcare access for all. However, in reality, it doesn’t work as hundreds of thousands are suffering and hundreds if not thousands are dying. It’s a real scandal. There needs to be reform of a lot of these institutions but there is no political desire to do so”. 

“There is a very debilitating status quo consensus on all aspects of the welfare state. Liz Truss tried to break it, but her premiership collapsed in chaos unfortunately” .

We joke that after the Truss experiment it will be a long time until someone attempts reform on a similar scale again. On the subject of mistakes, I ask Heath whether he’s ever written a piece that he really regretted. 

“God, I’ve written a lot; I couldn’t really tell you. There are things I regret and there are calls I think I got wrong. Definitely in the case of the Iraq War I was in favour of the invasion, and that was a terrible disaster, so that was something I got very badly wrong”. 

With our former Prime Minister set to be on manoeuvres again this year, I ask Heath whether Boris’ first comeback will be at The Telegraph. 

Pausing to think, he says “I doubt it, but I have no idea”. 

We wrap up with me asking him for a bold political prediction for the year ahead. 

“No one predicted anything that happened in 2022 so this is very hard. The most interesting known unknown is whether Rishi Sunak can substantially reduce Keir Starmer’s opinion poll lead. If he can’t, then he is in real trouble. You’ve also got what is going to happen with American politics. What’s going to happen to Russia? Will Ukraine defeat Russia? What about Vladimir Putin?”. 

We finish with Heath, as ever, asking all the big questions we don’t have answers to yet, but which the year will surely reveal soon. 

Quickfire:

France or Britain? Britain

Whiskey or wine? Neither

Town or country? Suburbs

FT or the The Economist? The Wall Street Journal

Walk in the drizzle or feet up by the fire? Walk in the drizzle

If you could take one album with you on a desert island, what would it be?

“Can I take a book, actually a kindle collection. I’d have to take a few Economics classics”. 

You can follow Allister Heath on Twitter @Allister Heath and read his weekly column every Wednesday on The Telegraph website. 

Image: Allister Heath