All is not okay: a response to ‘Three cheers for boring politics’

By Jack Kellamsecretlondon123

Patrick Brennan’s rather bizarre article on today’s election makes such a number of surprising and often frankly implausible claims, that I’ll probably have trouble tackling them all within a word count short enough to fit a normal-sized article – but I’ll give it my best shot nonetheless.

From what I gather, the article makes two main claims, the first descriptive and the second normative, although both are related:

1)      Today’s general election is “boring, orderly and predicable”. For the most part we know what is going to happen, and “the stats won’t let us down”.

2)      This is “heart-lifting… [because] it means everything is working”. Some things could be improved, but on the whole, ‘stability’ is indicative of success.

Looking at the first claim, you’d be surprised to hear any professional political scientist or pollster giving that opinion. Indeed, they don’t – as an article in the Guardian yesterday pointed out. Yes, most of the final polls have Labour and the Conservatives on roughly the same national vote share (around 33-34%), but the final outcome is still up in the air for a host of reasons.

Firstly, the margin of error in these polls is around 3-4%, which may not sound like much, but late swings either way in an election this close could make a decisive difference come Friday morning.

This is confounded by the sheer uneven and unprecedented party landscape of this election. No one can be sure to what extent the massive swings towards the SNP in Scotland will hold up, or how much UKIP will eat into both Tory and Labour votes in certain constituencies.

Predictions were far easier to make when Britain was by and large dominated by the two main parties – know the swing in only a few constituencies and you could produce a very accurate picture of the composition of the new parliament. The “unpredictable” landslides (which ones were these?) mentioned by Brennan were in fact far easier to predict today’s election.

However, the size and uneven distribution of the SNP, UKIP and Green votes makes such confident predictions far more difficult, shown by the uncertainty and qualifications with which most pollsters have outlined their forecasts.

Secondly, the delicate nature of the hung parliament we are likely to be faced with, leaves exactly what government we’ll shortly be under very much in the balance too. A few seats either way could mean the difference between another Conservative-Lib Dem coalition or some, very much still unpredictable, form of Labour minority government, backed up by other parties in any variety of combinations.

In terms of policy, this could mean the difference between a referendum on EU membership within the next few years, a significant difference in the amount cut in public spending, and whether or not the Bedroom Tax stays in place – I could go on (more on this shortly).

Also, every seat and every vote is likely to make a difference to the dynamics of subsequent negotiations. Cameron appears to be indicating that if he wins the most seats and the most votes, then his party will be the most ‘legitimate’ – regardless of the size of the ‘anti-Tory’ block against him. The more Labour can close down the gap in seats and votes, the less power Cameron’s argument will have.

So the exact outcome of the election is far from predictable – certainly less so than most general elections in the last 30 years (even 2010 and 1992). The sweeping statements made by Brennan really don’t stand up to much scrutiny.

Nevertheless, even if the exact outcome is conceded as up in the air, at least it will be decided by peaceful democratic procedure, Brennan might argue. The fact that we aren’t all killing each other over it must mean that something is going well. Right – where should I start?

Firstly, our peaceful democratic procedure isn’t even that democratic in the first place. The minor problems that Brennan seems to indicate are far more significant than he gives weight.

I’m lucky that my home constituency – Cardiff North – is a Labour-Tory marginal, which last time only had around 140 votes between first and second place. In our increasingly archaic first-past-the-post system, my vote will count for far more than some of my friends who live in safe seats.

Tomorrow, UKIP (love them or loathe them) will feel pretty hard done by if they achieve a double-digit score nationally, but only win a couple of seats. The SNP meanwhile could have around 50 from only a fraction of the number of votes.

What’s more, as my discussion of the forthcoming hung parliament suggests, the only argument that was left for FPTP – that it produced strong governments – has fallen by the wayside. Constitutionally, we’re a farce. This isn’t even mentioning the House of Lords. Or the Monarchy.

This brings me to the next corker: “Unpredictable election results are features of countries ravaged by civil war, unrest and civilian casualty. In a country this boring, you know that people are being looked after in good schools and hospitals. Not being shot at.”

I’ve obviously already argued why this election isn’t very predictable, but I’ll concede that point for now. The rest of the claim here comes from the classic “well, it could be so much worse, so stop moaning and appreciate what you’ve got – you whining lefties should try living in Somalia” line of argument.

I won’t mention that some of the most predictable election results come in one party states, which are also very ‘stable’, but arguably aren’t that great a place to live (North Korea anyone?).

Anyway, the writer Conor Kilpatrick has recently discussed this style of ‘privilege politics’ in far more depth than I will here – so I suggest you also read his work.

Just because we’re lucky enough to have some public services and aren’t subject to the same extremes of poverty as other countries, doesn’t entail that everything is remotely good either here too.

In fact, it actually spits right in the face of the 1,000,000 people forced to use food banks, and the most vulnerable in society who have been pummelled over the last 5 years – through draconian benefit sanctions, the socially sadistic bedroom tax, and poverty wages.

This is before I could even mention the sub-human conditions that undocumented migrants seeking asylum in our country are forced to endure in horrific detention centres like Yarl’s Wood.

The blood on the hands of our government when it withdrew support for an already inadequate maritime rescue scheme off the Italian coast, which sought to rescue those fleeing conflicts rooted in our own disastrous foreign policy, is also particularly salient.

These aren’t reasons to be content and “warm-hearted”: our country is a lot less “stable” than Brennan makes out.

Be angry, and don’t settle for the injustices faced by the most vulnerable in our society, just because it is worse elsewhere. Patting ourselves on the back for our apparent civility can only distract us from the magnitude of tasks at hand.

Photograph: secretlondon123