All Hail the King: What does Mbappé’s new contract mean for the state of football?
By Hugo Millard
On the 21st of May, Kylian Mbappé penned his signature on “the most expensive contract in football history” keeping him at the Parc des Princes until 2025, while costing PSG an eye-watering 450 million euros.
Although he has tried to deflect attention away from both, his decision was undoubtedly influenced by the record-breaking salary as well as the fact that the “sporting project has changed”. This is a vague description, with one possible suggestion being an increased influence on his part regarding board decisions.
However, both demonstrate his near priceless value on and off the pitch, with even Emmanuel Macron wading in on the saga by helping persuade him to stay in the French capital.
The global reaction to this news was understandably varied, with many raising eyebrows at the remarkable amount of money involved.
Most notably Javier Tebas, the president of the Spanish Football Federation, released a statement after the announcement accusing state-owned clubs of “not wanting to respect the rules of a sector as important as football” and acting in a manner that “puts at risk the integrity of the sport.” This was in relation to the huge financial losses that PSG have reported over previous seasons and questioned the role of financial fair play in their spending.
While also sparking a war of words between the French and Spanish clubs, it reignited discussion surrounding a problem which, in recent years, has taken hold of not only football but sport at the highest level: sports washing. Newcastle’s recent takeover was subject to much scrutiny on this topic given the human rights record of Saudi Arabia, which has strong ties to the investment fund which purchased the Magpies.
Nevertheless, investigations uncovered active efforts by the British government to grease the wheels of the deal, citing Saudi Arabia’s position as an important trading partner as a primary factor.
In the case of PSG, which is owned by Qatar Sports Investments, there is thought that keeping Mbappé was vital in further cleaning up the image of their controversial World Cup later this year. This controversy, again, stems from the country’s human rights record, criticised after the death of thousands of migrant workers building infrastructure for the tournament, as well as their treatment of the LQBTQ+ community. However, again, money lies at the heart of the situation, with the 2015 FIFA corruption case the result of Qatar’s selection as host.
So, what does this mean for the transfer market in the future? Nothing very good is the answer. Over the last decade, PSG and Manchester City, both state-owned, have the highest net spending in the world with 941 million euros and 984 million euros spent, respectively.
The Parisians also top the wage bill list by some distance, a figure which at the start of 2021/22 came in at 260 million euros annually. This is a cause for great concern, considering that this number was from before Mbappé renewed his contract with the club.
What does this mean for the transfer market in the future? Nothing very good is the answer.
Many have hailed this deal as completely unprecedented in football; however, there are examples of governments having influence in and aiding the spending of football clubs in the past, making the nature of La Liga’s complaints particularly ironic.
In 2021, both Barcelona and Real Madrid were forced to repay millions of illegal state aid that had been granted to them in the form of tax breaks and subsidies, adding to their advantage over rivals. This was a particular target of the French Football Federation, who hit back at La Liga’s statement, citing the grave mismanagement of Spanish clubs which has left the likes of Barça and Real drowning in debt.
While not necessarily in the wrong, Tebas’ actions, can certainly be seen as somewhat bitter and even sanctimonious to an extent. They are clearly founded on a desire to help build La Liga up from the dire mishandling of his league’s top clubs, which has led to the departure of superstars such as Messi and Ronaldo. These moves have resulted in a catastrophic loss of interest in the jewel of La Liga’s crown – El Clásico – something which the signing of a modern Galactico such as Mbappé would have, to a certain extent, helped to restore.
While the likes of Tebas are clearly arguing from a weak position, there is no doubt that this deal has huge ramifications for football as a whole; ramifications that are unquestionably negative. Not only will it serve to widen the ever-increasing gap between top and bottom in the European football pyramid, but it also shows that, unlike many football giants of the past who have come and gone, there is no sign of any halt in the cash flow to these clubs.
This can also be seen in the recent emergence of Saudi-backed LIV Golf, which is backed by the same investment fund which owns Newcastle. Surely governments and football’s governing bodies see what is wrong with allowing such money to come into the game and its aid in state-funded sports washing?
Recent events at Stamford Bridge and the treatment of Roman Abramovich have unequivocally shown that they do. However, when there are huge economic benefits on the line, as in the case of Saudi Arabia and Qatar, they are unwilling to put morals above profits. Something has to change.
Image: Balkan Photos via Flickr

