Alice review: ‘lost’
By Mei Carrick
It was strongly advised to check out the programme before DU Ballet Company’s Alice, which was released several days ahead of the production. This stuck me as rather odd – I’ve never had to do any prerequisite study for a leisurely pursuit. Nevertheless, I pushed any misgivings aside and took a look. Three things in particular captured my attention: the professional drawing on the front; the sheer number of scenes – a grand total of seventeen, each with an explanation; and the title “Our Guide To Not Getting Lost”. Maybe they were trying to be ironic, referring to the fact that our heroine, Alice (Emily Puumala), gets pretty lost in all manner of ways. Maybe they weren’t. Either way, the misgivings were back.
The need to clarify the plot using the programme took away a bit of the magic. A ballet is not just a dance. It is also a wonderful, dazzling and fabulous array of drama, music and art, which combine to tell a story. You shouldn’t need much, if any, guidance; you should be swept along with the performance. This didn’t quite apply to this production, but I did enter into the theme of the ballet. I got lost.
Individually, the quality of the dance and acting was fantastic. The cheeky faces of the Mad Hatter (Katharine Flach) and the foreboding pursed red lips of the Queen of Hearts (Charlotte Douglas) were particular highlights. The choreography was especially excellent at expressing personality through the dance. Tweedle Dee (Natalie Keogh) and Tweedle Dum (Lizzie Blenkinsop) were comically bouncy and the Cheshire Cats (Sasha Waloff and Rhiannon Hill) smooth and sly.
The use of multiple dancers to form the caterpillar was inspired (Anna Pengilly, Jiayan Tan, Lizzie Tones, Amelia Lenanton and Georgina Roberts). The flowing scarves they wore were a fine example of how costumes add to a performance.
Alice herself was a good choice of casting, though it was surprising that she never donned a pair of pointe shoes, whilst other dancers in less prominent roles did. Alice’s alter ego (Briana Dunlop) was convincingly dark and menacing, though I was confused, at points, as to whether she almost fell over or her dancing was part of her character.
Together this group of dancers were not quite as impressive. The synchronisation was a bit questionable at points, and the lack of plot throughout really took away from the ballet. Almost every scene was so short that it was easy to miss what had occurred. I often found myself thinking, “Is that it?” The frequent and unnecessary blackouts between scenes made the production appear like a series of individual dances. Each were very entertaining, but hindered attempts to follow the story, overzealous programme or no. The entire thing should have been more like the Mad Hatter’s Tea Party. This was a truly fantastic scene. The music was well chosen and the performers leapt onto and off the stage in a wonderfully mad way. This displayed a thoughtful use of space that produced a flow and rhythm that was missing from the overall ballet.
What was most baffling, moreover, was the need for an alter ego at all. The general impression was that the company were going for a black swan/white swan parallel (from Swan Lake, for those who are slightly perplexed), adapted to a more modern performance. I was expecting, therefore, the other Alice to cause trouble, to be the obvious baddie, finally vanquished with a dramatic dance-off finale. Instead, we got a short duet, which ended rather abruptly. Her alter ego was seen rather erratically throughout, not being particularly troublesome in anyway. I didn’t see the need for Alice to defeat her, they should have just left her alone – she wasn’t doing any harm.
All in all, the performance was above my expectations. The choice of music splendidly aided the good dance and drama, and the costumes were well thought out, though minimal. It was easily observable that the dancers themselves enjoyed the performance.
However, the plot went to pot.
Photograph: DU Ballet Company, FacebookÂ
