Agriculture, leading the world’s doom

By: Charles Kershaw

The millions that have died in the Holocaust, the World Wars, the third of the global population killed by Genghis Khan, every genocide, enslavement and extinction would never have occurred

Our history is an intricate mesh of events, all colliding with one another. Every action we make in our lives is a participation in events that will become a part of our global history. Some events have greater impact than others, and the knock-on effect of them can be felt for centuries. In the modern age, there is one event that if I could I would travel back through the sands of time and stop from ever happening. That event is the discovery of agriculture, first in the Fertile Crescent, between 7,000 and 10,000 years ago. The world has been shaken by untold suffering and hardship ever since.

This might seem like too consequential an event to change. Anthropologists consider the discovery of agriculture to be the beginning of civilisation; after hunter-gatherer societies learnt how to farm fields and store grain, they no longer had to be constantly on the move looking for food and could stay in one place. They then settled and built villages, which expanded over time to towns and cities, until city-states and nations were born. There was now more time for other activities, and it is often thought that at this point culture and technology developed, and over the millennia since civilisation’s founding we have experienced many innovations that have made our lives easier. Once we walked everywhere, then we could ride horses, then we rode in carts, then cars, then we could sail through the sky at hundreds of miles an hour to any destination on the planet.

The world has been shaken by untold suffering and hardship ever since

All this I imagine that you and the majority think has benefited us, and on the surface I might agree with you. I like the comforts of the modern world; I would be a hypocrite if I didn’t admit this. But if we had never been exposed to these comforts, we wouldn’t miss them. We might live like kings compared to our medieval ancestors, with access to the internet, clean water, a machine that washes our clothes for us, but many of us are still unhappy. A large amount of our happiness is dictated by our expectations— if we expect to have a certain amount of things, then we are unhappy when we don’t have them, and that expectation rises every time a new piece of technology is invented that is meant to make our lives easier.

Beyond this, the founding of civilisation set in motion an uncountable amount of suffering, of unspeakably large proportions, that could only have happened with the unification of masses of people and advances in weaponry. The millions that have died in the Holocaust, the World Wars, the third of the global population killed by Genghis Khan, every genocide, enslavement and extinction would never have occurred— a small price to pay for a lack of iPhones and instant coffee. The philosopher Lucretius says, “not in far times did one day give over to doom thousands”. And, as global warming hurtles us closer towards greater and greater catastrophes, we should think about how much destruction we have caused not only ourselves but for every living thing on the planet for our selfish greed.

An anarcho-primitivist society would not be a utopia, of course not; you might argue that I romanticise a hunter-gatherer society in which we would mostly die aged 35 of something very curable by modern medicine, and live rather boring and arduous lives. Yet we could also live a life of freedom, free from the burden of oppressive hierarchical structures that subjugate and exploit, in small groups of valued people, happy for every small joy bestowed upon us by the world, and hardened to accept the inevitable harshness of life.

Image: C. Roose via Creative Commons