African football: a symbol of hope, misery and frustration
By Max Daniels
Africa has taken its fair share of hits recently. And that is before we consider its football. Fears over the spread of Ebola meant the ongoing Africa Cup of Nations was relocated from Morocco to Equatorial Guinea just months before kick-off. What is more significant, however, is that such challenges are nothing new. The tournament and African football in general have been marred by drop-outs, corruption scandals and dire results, volatility matched only by Africa’s social, economic and political history. Yet there are also surprising results, optimism and a seemingly slow yet constant improvement. Football, like nowhere else, is representative of wider society.

African football seemed to have been developing so well in recent decades, but appears to have stagnated yet again. Tunisia won the continent’s first World Cup game in 1978, and by the end of the 1980s, an African country (Morocco) reached the knockout stages. After Cameroon beat titans Argentina in the 1990 finals, it appeared things would inevitably improve, such that Pele even predicted an African nation would win the World Cup before 2000.
How naïve of the Brazilian legend. Yes, these performances have been maintained, but progress has stalled in terms of results. Senegal reached the 2002 quarter-finals, yet Tunisia, Nigeria, South Africa and Cameroon all exited at the group stage. Ghana were the continent’s sole representative in the knockout phase in both 2006 and Africa’s own World Cup four years later (even if they were bundled out of the tournament at the quarter-final stage by a Luis Suarez handball). It would be foolhardy even of Pele to repeat such a statement.
The World Cup may be football’s highest stage, but a better indication of the state of African football is the continent’s own tournament, where politics seems to take over. Considering its history, the African Cup of Nations has a surprising robustness, having always taken place since its inception. Yet things could not have got off to a worse start when South Africa were disqualified in the inaugural 1957 tournament for their government’s insistence of sending an exclusively white squad. Bafana Bafana were only readmitted in 1996 when they staged and won the twentieth competition, a feat possible simply because the original hosts, Kenya, failed to invest in its facilities.
In recent years, the drama has only intensified. A horrific attack on the Togo team bus travelling to the tournament in which three were killed saw them miss the 2010 Cup, while Libya presented hosting duties to South Africa for 2013 because of security concerns after the toppling of Muammar Gaddafi (Libyan and Tunisian players still took part in 2012 despite their involvement in military campaigns). The current tournament reflects the continent’s latest crisis, when Morocco, having asked for a delay because of fears over the spread of Ebola, were disqualified and replaced as hosts by Equatorial Guinea.
So what has created this messy situation where the only constant is underperformance? Fundamentally, it is an issue of mismanagement and lack of resources. On the whole, the game is so badly run that what few resources exist rarely improve performance. FIFA has invested $476m in African football since 1999, a sizeable sum (alongside private money) that should lead to progress; but corruption, “is synonymous with African football,” according to one academic, who describes how officials often misappropriate funds meant for infrastructure and developing. One example he highlights is a $600,000 investment by phone company MTN in a Cameroonian stadium-improvement project that saw $146,000 end up in the sports minister’s pockets, with the rest unaccounted for. Needless to say the work never happened.
There is also a lack of overall funding, regardless of how much leaks to dirty hands. FIFA’s investment pales into insignificance when compared European figures, such as the £85m invested per year in youth development in the Bundesliga alone which reveals why there is such a stark divide between the two continents. A lack of investment prevents the best players being found, and restricts the opportunities for the considerable talent that does exist in Africa, meaning both clubs and countries suffer. The talented players lucky enough to be coached almost always find themselves in Europe. This can be problematic not least for the players, some of whom find themselves sent home or destitute as part of what has been described as human trafficking, or even neo-colonialism.
The situation, as always, is not helped by FIFA, who insist upon a policy of ‘non-interference’ whereby governments are prevented from influencing the decision-making of football associations. In principle this makes sense: politics should play no role in football. However, in practice it means there is no effective oversight of national football associations, allowing corruption to fester amongst the game’s governors. Kenya’s team were banned in 2004 because of government interference, even though football officials allegedly stole $700,000 of FIFA funding. FIFA’s hypocrisy is the worst aspect, having intervened before the 2010 World Cup by lobbying the South African government for a $600m reconstruction of the Green Point Stadium in Cape Town. John Comitis, CEO of Ajax Cape Town, provided a better alternative of redeveloping Newlands stadium (found in a more deprived part of Cape Town) and constructing training facilities throughout the city, at a cost of just $20m. Peter Alegi, author of African Soccerscapes, suggests that constructing such showpieces, “could actually weaken recreational sport in marginalised communities and may possibly result in the withdrawal of financial resources that were previously allocated for a plethora of pressing socio-economic needs.”
African football is representative of the wider struggles that the continent faces: corruption, lack of investment, political struggles and abject poverty. And it requires similar solutions to society at large, including reforms that improve accountability and reduce corruption. This may inspire more external investment in developing players and coaches to improve performance on the pitch, and the stadia and infrastructure that would allow fans to support their teams. There is hope, as evidenced by the large number of African players in top European leagues. However, such improvement is a significant challenge that requires more than the guidance of football authorities.
Photograph: wikipedia
