Admissions policies should not be dumbed down, claims St Andrew’s Vice-Principal

by Joanna Thom

A controversial statement released by St Andrews University this week claimed that admissions policies should not be dumbed down to achieve a more socially balanced student body.

Stephen Magee, St Andrew’s Vice-Principal with responsibility for admissions, said that politicians could not continue to “lay responsibility for widening access solely at the door of universities.”

This comes after numerous appeals by the government for the top universities to widen their access and accept more students from lower income families.

Recently SNP ministers in Edinburgh have been demanding that Scottish universities sign new “outcome agreements” that will see them given public funding on the condition they agree to “widen access.”

St Andrews was strongly criticised for admitting only 14 students from the poorest backgrounds last year. While the university has promised to make an effort to widen its access, Mr Magee said that the blame could not be pinned solely on the universities but some responsibility had to start being taken by the rest of the system.

He stressed that efforts should be made to raise the standards in schools and to help the students aspire towards the top universities.
Universities who do not widen their access risk fines and may not be allowed to charge students the maximum tuition fee price of ÂŁ9,000.

59% of Durham students are from state schools, compared to a national average of 93%

Many of the top universities in Britain admit proportionally more privately educated students.

Durham is among these universities, with 59% of its latest intake from state schools despite the fact that in Britain 93% of students attend state schools. It has recently taken steps towards increasing its intake from lower income families by expanding its bursary system to increase the amount awarded to the lowest income students, and to increase the number of students eligible for financial support.

While getting rid of financial barriers that might prevent students applying will help to improve access, critics have warned that this may not help those talented students who could be very successful at the top universities but do not have the academic qualifications required because of their backgrounds. However, lowering grade boundaries to widen access may compromise the integrity of the top universities and lead to calls that students from top schools are being discriminated against.

Photograph: Durham University