Act of Union Under Threat
Tensions are rising over the continuation of the 1707 Act of Union between England and Scotland.
Alex Salmond made a pledge to hold a referendum in 2014, however disagreement is mounting over when a referendum might take place. London and Edinburgh dispute who has the legality and legitimacy to call a referendum.
Those in support of London cite Parliamentary Sovereignty, which appears to be supported by public law authorities.
Edinburgh however argues that Parliamentary Sovereignty is distinctly English with “no counterpart in Scottish Constitutional Law.”
Regardless of whether or not the referendum’s outcome would be binding, the Scottish National Party ‘s claim that a positive vote for independence in a referendum would have “enormous moral and political force… impossible for a future [Westminster] government to ignore” is a valid one.
In their view this would give the Scottish Parliament a mandate to negotiate an act of secession with the Westminster.
David Cameron is demanding that any referendum must take place within 18 months, to avoid the economy being damaged by uncertainty. He also says there should be two options for Scotland: “in or out”.
This puts him at odds with Scotland’s First Minister who, in addition to wanting the referendum in 2014, argues for a third option, “devomax”; deep devolution leaving little more than defence and foreign policy in Westminster’s hands.
The general view is that the later the referendum takes place, the greater the chances of Scotland voting for independence is. Opinion polls in Scotland suggest the proportion of people who want full independence is growing, but slowly.
If the referendum were in 2014, many government cuts will have affected Scotland, which has a higher proportion of public sector workers than England.
Salmond also wants to capitalise on nationalist sentiment running high in 2014 which sees the 700th Anniversary of The Battle of Bannockburn, and both the Commonwealth Games and the Ryder Cup being held in the country.
The extent of the implications of independence is unclear; issues surrounding the armed forces, the British Pound, and foreign policy are widely spoken about.
Depending on Scotland’s status within the EU and how Salmond’s desire for ‘good neighbourly ties’ was settled, Scottish students could even be expected to pay international fees.
Many doubt that Scotland would be able to continue avoiding £9,000 tuition fees, potentially leading to a typical Scottish degree of four years costing £36,000. Scottish Academics could be hit if they lost their high share of the UK Research Council Grants.
Particularly important is how an independent Scotland would fair economically. Some commentators believe this would depend largely on the amount of North Sea Oil that Scotland obtained and how long the oil would last.
However, the SNP maintain that an independent Scotland would have a strong economy, separate from England’s. Only time will tell to see how Scotland would fare if, and when, Scotland becomes independent.

