Accommodation fees: the joke is over
By Harry Cross
College rents at Durham have risen again and have now topped £7,000 per year for the first time. This is in contrast with when I came to Durham in 2011 when a room in college cost less than £5,000. As co-chair of Durham Students for University Reform I have led the campaign on campus against this precipitous rise in fees and its harmful effects on our academic community.
For the past year, our organisation has tried to engage the University in an open and transparent discussion about the need for such large rent hikes, including through the official channels of the Students’ Union. And yet, we have repeatedly come up against a wall of, at best, indifference or, at worst, contempt and hypocrisy.
The University has repeatedly issued the line (quoted verbatim) that “we have been transparent about our costs and remain competitive in terms of our accommodation pricing” and that students “benefit from a college experience at halls of residence prices”. That this is palpably untrue (catered accommodation at Durham is £2,000 more expensive than at nearby York or Newcastle) is seemingly of no concern.
The appointment of a new Vice-Chancellor, Professor Stuart Corbridge, led many to hope that the manner in which the University dialogued with staff and students would change substantially, even if concrete changes in University policy would take longer to materialise. Sadly, Professor Corbridge’s honeymoon lasted less than two months and his desire to establish an open and respectful dialogue with the University community has apparently failed to permeate through to rest of the University’s governing bodies.
Indeed, the e-mail to students announcing that rents would rise by 3.5% made no attempt to honestly address student concerns regarding college affordability. Rather, it sought to dismiss or rebut these concerns. For instance, the statement that “The inflation in the costs associated with delivering College Accommodation is different from the generally quoted ‘inflation rate’ and are [sic] significantly different from that which affects people in the national economy” misses a fundamental point: the reason students frequently cite the sharp disparity between the rate of inflation of college rents and any comparable increases in inflation, wages or maintenance loans is not to call into question the basis of the University’s fanciful accounting methods but rather to make the point that the price of college accommodation is rapidly outstripping people’s ability to pay.
In a recent Q&A with students, the Vice-Chancellor outlined five priorities in the University’s long-term strategic vision. These included increasing diversity in the student body and reinforcing Durham’s collegiate identity. And yet, the upwards spiral of college rents is deleterious to both these goals. On the one hand, the financial burden of living in Durham is deterring many gifted students from applying here. On the other, Durham’s unique college experience is becoming a two-tier experience determined by one’s ability to live in during final year. Nor can one escape by living out: private rents in Durham are rising by 5% per year as a direct knock-on effect of spiralling college rents, creating a rent crisis in Durham city.
As an activist, I acknowledge that the University is subject to financial constraints. However, for a dialogue based on mutual trust to emerge between students and the University it is essential that the University acknowledges the very real concerns of students regarding college affordability. For too long, the University has strung students along with implausible explanations regarding accommodation charges seeking to evade any substantive discussion. The joke is now over. Student campaigners are struggling to save the best of our University from the destructive policies of its executive. It’s high time for a rethink.
Photograph: William Pinkney-Baird
