Abortion: Safe, free and legal

By Durham Students for Abortion Access

This is a response to an article written by Durham Students for Life. All views expressed here are of Durham Students for Abortion Access.  

Abortion is a fundamental healthcare right that should be safe, free and legal to all those who choose to access it. Whatever choice an individual makes, they have a right to do so and be fully supported throughout this. Pro-life discussions can be dangerous and create unsafe spaces for those who have accessed or are accessing abortions. Abortion is a difficult decision to make, both emotionally and physically. These difficulties do not need to be exacerbated by uninvolved parties misguided by pseudoscience. It’s simple; if you don’t agree with abortion, don’t have one.

We know from the numerous messages we’ve received to our page that women are silenced after their abortions, shamed into not speaking out and stigmatized for their decision. We need to create a platform upon which individuals can safely speak out about their decision, and it is only in this way that we can support individuals and reduce the stigma of having an abortion. No matter how much Durham Students for Life claim they are not about ‘shaming’ or ‘blaming’, their use of the phrase “vulnerable women” to describe women who choose to have abortions is certainly problematic. Let’s step away from this saviour complex, and trust that women are able to make the right decision for themselves. Not your body? Not your choice.

When talking about abortions, women’s voices should speak the loudest

This stigma is only exacerbated when discussions about abortion, such as Durham Students for Life’s ‘A Voice for the Voiceless’, are filled with male voices and opinions. According to witnesses at the event, the majority of attendees were male, while the predominantly female protesters were literally locked outside of a discussion to do with their own bodies, with a threat of police action if we were to enter the discussion. When talking about abortions, women’s voices should speak the loudest.

It is rather worrying that Durham Students for Life used such unsound evidence to support their claims about abortion. Let’s look into what they said. Does abortion increase the risk of infertility and haemorrhaging? No, there is no increased health risk to those who choose to have abortions. When health complications do arise, these result from individuals engaging in unsafe, illegal abortions due to tighter abortion restrictions. You can never get rid of abortion; you can only get rid of safe abortion.

What about the research from Priscilla Coleman claiming that women who have undergone an abortion experience an 81% increased risk of mental health problems? What Durham Students for Life failed to mention about this is the extremely high levels of criticism this research has faced. Not only has further research using the exact dataset and methodology failed to reproduce these findings (Steinberg and Finer, 2011), Coleman’s findings have been repeatedly described as “logically inconsistent” and “substantially inflated” by faulty methodology (Stein, 2010). Indeed, the American Psychological Association and other major medical bodies have concluded that evidence does not support a link between abortion and mental health problems (APA, 2018).

It is essential we provide individuals with the right to choose what happens to their body, and support them through this decision

They also fail to consider the impact forcing a pregnancy to continue to full term can have for both the mother and child. Gilchrist (1995) found that women who were forced to carry an unwanted pregnancy to full term were more likely to commit suicide, and this risk increased twofold for those who were denied an abortion. Najman et al (1995) found that women carrying an unwanted pregnancy were at a five times greater risk of depression when compared to a control group, with a similar trend observed for anxiety. David (2006) found that children born to mothers twice denied abortions had a significantly increased risk of developing mental illness, with 13.9% of only children becoming in-patients compared to 0% in the control group. Therefore, when considering the mental and physical effects of abortion, it is important we look at both sides. It is essential we provide individuals with the right to choose what happens to their body, and support them through this decision.

It must also be highlighted that a pregnancy crisis centre offers a very different experience to an abortion clinic. For those unaware, a pregnancy crisis centre is a ‘fake clinic’ set up by anti-abortion groups, which mislead women and provide medically inaccurate information about abortion. They often withhold essential medically accurate reproductive health information, and lead clients to believe that they are visiting a neutral and objective medical facility (Planned Parenthood, 2014). Therefore, when the President claims that women state they ‘wish someone had told me what abortion is really like’, women receiving advice from pregnancy crisis centres still do not know what abortion is really like, as they are fed pro-life myths, such as those debunked above. How can you claim to love and support women if you are actively lying to them to influence decisions about their body?

Whether you choose to carry on with pregnancy or not, the choice is always yours

Ultimately, the rights of a living human being come before any ‘rights’ of a foetus. Despite Durham Students for Life’s claims, there are numerous important differences between humans and foetuses. Let’s start with the obvious; a foetus is not a person and does not have international human rights. A foetus before 24 weeks is not viable without the mother. In 5% of cases when a baby is born at 22 weeks, it can survive. But in only 2% of these cases will the child live without severe impairment (Wright, 2019). Foetuses do not feel pain due to the fact that the connections necessary in the brain to transmit signals of pain do not develop until 24 weeks (American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists). Thus, to argue that there is no difference between a foetus and a human ignores very obvious scientific differences. It is, therefore, a human rights violation to put the ‘right’ of a foetus above the right of a living human being, and to force pregnancy to be carried to full term.

If the focus is on love and supporting women, then let’s ensure that it’s on supporting women making their own choice rather than stigmatizing them for their decisions and shaming them into silence. Whether you choose to carry on with pregnancy or not, the choice is always yours.

Image by Edson Chilundo via Flickr.