Abolishing Oxbridge will not improve social mobility
By Catriona Inglis
In July 2019, the Financial Times published an article titled ‘How Oxbridge distorts British life’ suggesting that removing Oxbridge at undergraduate level would increase social mobility in a similar way that it has done for Canada, Sweden and Australia. The article suggests that Oxbridge supercharges the social elite into positions of power leaving those not privileged enough to secure places lagging behind forever.
At first look, this article seems to have a point. After all of the fifty-five prime ministers Britain has had, 28 went to Oxford and 14 went to Cambridge. 24% of MPs elected in the 2017 elections went to Oxbridge. Considering that Oxbridge graduates make up less than 1% of the UK population, it does seem that a disproportionate number of Oxbridge graduates end up at Westminster. Comparatively, only 10 current MPs attended Durham university and no prime ministers so unfortunately it seems that Doxbridge, at least in Parliament, is not a thing.
However, the Financial Times is wrong to place the blame of the lack of social mobility in the UK exclusively on Oxbridge rather than the overall impact of elite private education. The article parallels the UK’s private school system with Canada, which has private schools but no elite universities. The article claims that as Canada is the most socially mobile country in the developed world and has fee-paying schools but no elite universities, elite universities, not private schools are what prevent upward mobility.
However, this argument is fundamentally flawed as Canada, Sweden and Australia all have something else that the UK doesn’t: well-funded state schools. In the UK the last year has seen teachers become increasingly overworked and underpaid and students, suffering from increasingly larger class sizes, have less special needs support and less funding. By blaming Oxbridge for the lack of social mobility, the Financial Times is suggesting that removing Oxbridge at undergraduate level will somehow prevent 18 years of family privilege and superior education from manifesting. Unfortunately, depriving the social elite of their three years at esteemed Oxbridge universities is not the solution to the UK’s class problem.
Depriving the social elite of their three years at esteemed Oxbridge universities is not the solution to the UK’s class problem
The gap between private and state education has always been large in the UK but it is an ever-growing gap. Although Boris Johnson has promised more funding for schools, this only raises it back to what it was a decade ago, which will not mitigate the effects of decades of cuts, nor solve the problem of the chronic lack of teachers caused by people leaving the profession at an astounding rate. It is true that 24% of MPs went to Oxbridge but perhaps the more shocking statistic is that 29% went to private schools. Considering that only 7% of the population are privately educated there definitely seems to be something going on here.
Even more shocking of the privately educated MPs, over 1 in 10 of them went to Eton. A total of 20 UK prime ministers went to Eton and the UK has only ever had 9 prime ministers who have been educated in non-fee-paying schools. Just nine.
Blaming Oxbridge for the social elite privileges of the few is perhaps then, a bit of a stretch. If anything, if the application system weren’t so distorted (with private schools better preparing their students for the interview process) Oxbridge could act as a great leveller, a place where talent and application could triumph over family and class. However, for as long as people are able to buy their way in, Oxbridge perhaps is just another place where our next generation of privately educated leaders go to finishing school before popping down to Westminster to administer yet another round of state school cuts.
Oxbridge could act as a great leveller, a place where talent and application could triumph over family and class
The Labour party is promising to remove the VAT exemption on private schools, something that has always been ludicrous as it relies on the ‘charitable status’ of private schools. Private schools have long claimed that this allows them to offer scholarships to less the financially fortunate however it is particularly nonsensical considering that state Sixth Form colleges are required to pay VAT. Whether this is enough is a matter for debate, however trying to shift the debate on social mobility from the problem of private schools onto Oxbridge only camouflages the real issue. As Durham students, it would be lovely to blame the UK’s problem on Oxbridge – we are all Oxbridge rejects after all. Alas, the facts speak louder than dreams. Oxbridge is only the symptom of the wider private school problem.
Photograph: RAMONRAMON via Flickr and Creative Commons
