A Working Theory of Love

Golden Gate Bridge

by Eva Hodgkin

Scott Hutchins’ debut novel is an original and thoroughly modern take on the male rom com; think High Fidelity but with a talking computer. Although Hutchins teaches on the Stanford fiction course, and writes for Esquire and The New York Times amongst others, A Working Theory of Love is, impressively, his first novel, and he has not hesitated to plunge in at the deep end.

The plot focuses on the life of Neil Bassett Jr., raised in small-town Arkansas by devout Catholics, but now living the feckless, disillusioned life of the divorced bachelor in San Francisco; an introspective, run-of-the-mill metrosexual looking for, as Hutchins puts it, ‘a lee in which to pitch the Bedouin tent of his soul’.

So far, so normal. However, soon Neill becomes entangled with a 20-year-old student with some pretty serious baggage of her own, not least the fact that she’s a member of an orgasm-oriented cult called Pure Encounters, ‘like Transcendentalism but with a focus on the genitals’. Insisting that he doesn’t have commitment issues, he finds himself caught between the 20-year-old, an attractive, older colleague, and his ex-wife, unsure whether they are ‘friends with benefits or friends with slight disadvantages’.

The most compelling aspect of A Working Theory of Love, which lifts it out of the realm of the normal ‘journey of discovery’-style rom com, is its simultaneous focus on the theme of artificial intelligence. Hutchins includes a quote at the beginning of the book from Alan Turing, the ground-breaking mathematician and code-breaker who first posed the question: Can a machine think for itself? Turing posited that if, during an ‘imitation game’, a typed conversation, a machine could be clever enough to fool a human being 30% of the time, then this could reasonably be classified as ‘thought’. This debate as to whether ‘there is no empirical difference between seeming and being’ is extended to other areas of the book, namely Neill’s relationships, particularly with women. Is love, he wonders, simply a case of fooling another person a sufficient percentage of the time?

Neill’s main contact with artificial intelligence comes via his workplace, a software company attempting to create Turing’s ‘human computer’, able to trick us into believing it’s one of our own. The complicating factor is that the computer programme has been based on his dead Father’s journals, only discovered after his suicide. The banal, often trivial contents of these journals, with their uptight truisms and affirmations of the Southern chivalric code, have been fed into the computer to give it a personality, a sense of self. Neill’s job is to instant message this electronic echo of his dead Father, to correct its English and make it seem more ‘present’; a deliberate irony, given that Neill’s main problem with his distant Father was his remoteness. However, as he begins to successfully resurrect ‘drbas’ (Dr Bassett), he begins to wonder if the programme could resolve the issues which Neill has been grappling with since his Father’s suicide: why he did it, whether he really loved his son and his wife and, with painful honesty, whether Neill really loved him.

These sections of the book combine humour with bathos and are arguably the most engaging, as Neill finds his difficult, stunted relationship with his Father re-played with a computer who repeats the same phrases parrot-like – ‘married people shouldn’t have friends across the sexes’ – and is liable to refuse to speak at all if Neill asks a question he doesn’t like.

However, the pared-down question-and-answer format of these sessions soon becomes a means of exploration and insight for both man and computer. Dr Bassett, or ‘drbas’, begins to question, from beyond the grave, his son’s life choices, asking Neill, the inveterate, unhappy singleton: ‘what good is a life spent alone?’ We share Neill’s frustration with his conservative, enigmatic Father, but also feel the full wrench of a relationship cut brutally short, exemplified by drbas’ inability to understand why Neill keeps referring to him in the past tense. Arguably the crux of the book can be seen in the question which Neill has been repeatedly asking himself, and finally gets to pose to his Father: ‘Is there something wrong with us?’

In a way the whole novel is a long series of questions, some philosophical, some funny. It encourages the reader to wonder: can ‘seeming’ equal being? Will humans soon be immortalised in the form of chips and wires? Is love, as their tech rival puts it, just ‘a mixture of need fulfilment and projection’? Perhaps most importantly, as Neill becomes increasingly disillusioned with the consumerist, liberal but often meaningless life that he leads, it also raises the familiar question that good books often do: is this the way we ought to live?

Hutchins does not become bogged down in profundities. Alongside these musings he demonstrates his ability to observe acutely the incidental details of human relationships, such as Neill tucking his hands into his pockets on meeting his ex-wife so that he can’t try to grab her hand. It is arguably these moments of very human uncertainty and doubt which prove more effective and touching than any of Neill’s earnest attempts to formulate a real working theory of love.

Scott Hutchins’ success at holding together a book of this breadth should not be underestimated. He manages to combine that most traditional of themes, the search for love and for an understanding of the self, and the most modern, the search for artificial intelligence; love, ‘a territory all its own’, ends up winning the day, perhaps unsurprisingly, by the end of the novel. However the real achievement here is that, along the way, this fast-paced and funny book forces the reader to engage with the question of what it means to be a real human being, in all senses of the term.

A Working Theory of Love, Scott Hutchins

Viking Adult

Photograph: Flickr, Mindwalker2076