A very British bill of rights
There’s something slightly sadistic about telling a finalist law student that the Human Rights Act is about to be abolished. This piece of legislation has, since the majority of its provisions entered into force fifteen years ago, permeated almost every area of British law in a way that even its strongest proponents would not have imagined possible. To teach UK law in the absence of the Human Rights Act (hereafter HRA) would be like teaching GCSE Science without mentioning either biology, chemistry or physics – academically intriguing but otherwise futile.
So to those students who have spent three years being drowned in a mass of law built on the HRA, its abolition sounds at first like a gift from the Gods and then seconds later it sinks in that suddenly your degree has lost quite a bit of relevance. It’s rather like a man who has spent three years building a brewery only to discover upon its completion that the world has turned tee-total.
But aside from purely selfish motives, the proposed abolition of the HRA should cause all of us some disquiet. Although premised on the idea (as seen in many national newspapers on the day of the Queen’s Speech) that the Act is an alien and foreign tool that defeats the decent “ordinary” man and allows paedophiles and murderers to triumph over good “British” common sense, this perception couldn’t be further from the truth. The HRA was so innovative not because it took sovereignty away from the UK but rather it empowered our own courts to take action to remedy human rights issues before they were taken to a court in Strasbourg at huge expense.
Very few actually want to withdraw from the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) that the UK incorporated into its own law through the HRA. The European Convention is infused with the post-war European desire (with a highly influential British input) to put some inalienable entitlements of every human being behind a curtain of legal protection, safe from the machinations of an over-zealous state. It would set a dangerous precedent for a lot of other countries who have signed up to human rights treaties (with which they have become rather bored) if the UK were to leave the ECHR, or weaken its position within UK law by abolishing the HRA.
So if we are to remain bound by this convention, is it really that outlandish to try and make public authorities live up to in the actions that they have signed their country up to on paper? And is it really abhorrent to suggest that our own courts can judge these issues rather than exporting them to Strasbourg and having all of the UK’s dirty laundry paraded about internationally?
This debate has become clouded by scaremongering and hyperbole. UK law won’t come crashing down if we abolish the HRA or, even worse, withdraw from the European Convention. But in this act we empowered our own courts to decide when international human rights standards have been broken, to if possible make slight linguistic changes in existing laws to remedy this or if not, tell Parliament that the law as it currently stood was in breach of human rights. In depriving them once again of this power, we have not reclaimed any sovereignty to the UK. More time will be spent managing lengthy appeals to Strasbourg rather than dealing with the issues in the UK.
In recent years many high profile cases, particularly over the deportation of terrorist suspects and foreign criminals and the question of prisoners’ voting rights, have allowed the ECHR and the HRA to fall into the cross-hairs of populist clamour. Yet as its achievements the ECHR can cite the curbing of torture by armed forces, the ending of the criminalisation of homosexuality (sparked by the UK’s laws in Northern Ireland) and perhaps most importantly in recent years ending the indefinite detention without trial of foreign prisoners on suspicion of terrorism offences in the UK.
In the last instance the ECHR merely rubber stamped the judgment given by a UK court using a UK law in the HRA to hold the UK government in breach of the obligations that it has declared all individuals are owed. The UK was sovereign, but not by placing all the rights of decision-making with the government or parliament alone but also by allowing the courts to play their part. It, like the HRA, was a very British affair.
Illustration: Mariam Hayat

