A Study in Crime: Elly Griffiths’ ‘The Stranger Diaries’

By Milly Munro

I picked this book up on a whim, having seen the cover in a newspaper recommendation. I had never heard of Elly Griffiths before reading this and by the end of the book, I was sorry that I hadn’t heard of her sooner.

It becomes almost impossible to try and pin the murders on a person as the novel progresses.

The Stranger Diaries centres around a small town in which a series of grisly murders occurs. The narrative alternates between Clare, an English teacher whose best friend is the first victim in a series of murders; Harbinder, the police detective assigned to solve the case and Clare’s daughter Georgia, who is keeping quite a few secrets from her mother. Griffiths uses the alternating narratives to tell the story from the differing perspectives which proves to be ingenious; the reader is able to understand the motives of multiple characters. It becomes almost impossible to try and pin the murders on a person as the novel progresses. It also means that Griffiths leaks suspicion into the story as some of the characters are not all that they appear at first.

Griffiths also keeps the reader guessing through the use of R. M. Holland; a fictional author who suffered through a similar series of murders in the past. For an extra element of creepiness, his old office happens to be in the school at the centre of the action – as R. M. Holland’s office, workplace of the victims and Georgia’s school. Griffiths inserts chapters from his story to give little hints as to what may be coming next in the present-day story, letting the tension build. It definitely adds a unique gothic side to the story.

Griffiths manages to keep this story realistic with the everyday struggles of the characters

Griffiths thankfully doesn’t go completely over the top with the horror side of things in this novel. She keeps it grounded within the realms of the real world as Clare is constantly riled by her ex-husband, and Georgia laments the struggles of living with parents who don’t know that she’s gay. Griffiths also bounces the characters off of each other; Clare and Harbinder aren’t exactly fond of each other when they meet, and it’s a really interesting twist to see the characters from each other’s perspective. Griffiths manages to keep this story realistic with the everyday struggles of the characters and avoids allowing the gothic elements of the novel to become overwhelming.

giving nothing away until the climax of the novel.

For anyone looking for a more gothic, dark mystery, this is definitely a good one to try. Griffiths keeps the reader guessing, giving nothing away until the climax of the novel. Both stories, the present day and the historic, come together very nicely (although with very different endings) and Griffiths makes sure that the reader is kept hooked.

Photograph: Clem Onojeghuo via Unsplash