A statement from the ‘Boycott the Durham Union’ campaign
By Fernanda Roig-Angeles
On the 8th July, Palatinate’s investigation into the Durham Union Society (DUS) revealed allegations of bigotry, bullying and malpractice. The truth is that this is neither new nor surprising. The Union’s foul reputation is common knowledge in Durham, and this is the second such article in five years.
Crucially, this year is different. The “Boycott the DUS” campaign, led by two former DUS Equalities Officers, is already gaining widespread support. It sounds radical – surely there are better ways to solve these issues than to target the resources and privileges of Durham’s oldest society?
Unfortunately, there aren’t. The issues run too deep; if that wasn’t proved by the countless hours put in by me and many others who now form the Boycott the DUS campaign to try and eke out the smallest reform, then put yourself in our shoes.
If you go to your average Union event, the ones open only to members, and not designed to recruit freshers at the beginning of term, there is a standard set-up.
Firstly, the debating room is often less than half full. I can recall a moment last year where, for a significant speaker, more people were campaigning for a presidential election outside than actually inside watching the event. Beyond the practical reasons for this, many just do not feel comfortable entering the chamber.
The Union’s foul reputation is common knowledge in Durham.
If there are a few dozen attendees, normally on a Friday night, then you will probably see a row of white men in black tie taking the front row. There’s nothing inherently uncomfortable about that – but when some of those men start laughing at or insulting the one token progressive or female speaker, you start to feel uncomfortable. Especially when it is these minority speakers who are often tasked with opposing the regularly drafted selection of notable right-wing columnists.
Suppose you’ve attended some of these debates, or even went to a mostly empty dreary social event at the Union bar (24s). You then decide, unlike the hundreds of others who wisely avoid the place they paid £65 for in freshers’ week, to try and change the organisation.
This can be a big mistake and is often where things get nasty. The more involved you get, the clearer it becomes that the DUS is almost entirely governed by senior members at the top of the Durham University Conservative Association. This tiny clique gets all their friends in to elect their successors – or just vote for names who never turn up, instead told to offer their proxy for elections at the next level of Union bureaucracy, the General Committee.
If you do manage to gather enough friends to vote you into a committee, you could experience often blatantly racist or sexist comments made against you. Then, you may also witness how the perpetrators would be defended by everyone around you as they keep their Union position and are allowed to repeat this behaviour.
It becomes easy to feel disheartened, isolated, but determined that there must be a way out of this – and until recently, there was. Those alienated campaigned for the one member who promised real reform as President. With an open process, the ridiculously low turnout sometimes increased as the general membership voted for an outsider.
The President would then present quite basic proposals – a proper code of conduct, real accountability for bigotry, open elections – which would then all be blocked by the clique in power.
The DUS…needs to reject its toxic culture and face up to this existential threat to its future.
Recently, that clique had enough of even that: they voted to amend the constitution so only those with past high-level officership experience can run for President in the first instance. This leaves elections unopposed, as to get to that point, you need the whip of those in control, opposed to relevant experience or expertise.
Many then choose to leave for good and that’s why this time is so different. We’ve [members of the ‘Boycott the DUS’ campaign] left, but we hate that this has happened to so many and that the cycle is allowed to continue. Durham as a community has a responsibility to stop supporting the DUS.
Everyone can join in. Stop going to 24s. Ask your societies, colleges and representatives to back the boycott and protect the welfare of their members. Ask businesses to stop sponsorships and ask the university to stop subsidising the organisation.
Freshers – trust me, that £65 can go so much further, and your hard work and talents will be appreciated far more elsewhere than it would be in an endless battle for reform in a society that does not value you or your efforts.
The DUS, or an equivalent society, could in theory be a brilliant place for debate and discussion in Durham. But for that to happen, and for free speech to genuinely be protected on campus, it needs to reject its toxic culture and face up to this existential threat to its future.
Fernanda Roig-Angeles is the Secretary of the “Boycott the Durham Union” campaign.
Image supplied by “Boycott the Durham Union” campaign.
