A Servant to Two Masters review: ‘took a few tumbles’

By Hannah McIntyre

This much beloved and highly anticipated farce took a few tumbles (planned and otherwise) on an uneven opening night but overall Castle Theatre Company’s production of A Servant to Two Masters came out on top.

Transplanting this often-adapted 18th Century farce from the canals of Venice to 1920s London was a stroke of genius on the part of director Jess Christy. Thanks largely to the sumptuous surroundings of Castle’s Senate Suite, the adaptation was utterly convincing. The production made full use of this privileged setting, greeting audience members in character as they directed them through the halls of the castle, and filling the space with jazz cranked from an old gramophone. The effect was quite stunning.

Expectations were high then amongst the audience and judging by the waves of laughter, were largely met. The veteran cast of Durham actors held their nerve with a tricky script and the added pressure of being nose to nose with their audience in the intimate setting.

Farce is notoriously difficult to get right, and with the weight of James Corden’s spectacular West End performance lingering in recent memory, Dominic McGovern had no mean feat on his hands with the role of Truffaldino. To say that he has a natural talent for physical comedy would be to massively understate the facts. As far as I’m concerned anyone who can keep an entire room enthralled simply by chewing on a piece of bread deserves all of the accolades I can think of. Always charming, and loveably daft, the performance was however not without its faults. McGovern stumbled over his lines on occasion, which may have gone unnoticed in another play, but here where so much rested on his witty delivery, you felt the absence.

Olivia Race as Smeraldina and Tash Taylor as Clarice in 'A Servant to Two Masters'
Olivia Race as Smeraldina and Tash Taylor as Clarice in ‘A Servant to Two Masters’

Keeping pace with the excellent lead performance was difficult, but Tyler Rainford as Pantaloon managed it with his perfectly deranged facial expressions. It is a special kind of talent to be able to portray rage to such an extent that the vein on your forehead reduces the audience to fits of laughter. Special mention should also go to Tash Taylor’s fantastically annoying wailing tantrums as Clarice, as well as the wonderfully named Smeraldina’s (Olivia Race) withering cynicism and dead-pan delivery.

The total, however, felt somehow less than the sum of its parts. A central scene, the dinner, should have brought the house down, yet the dodgy timing and the odd line which the cast simply didn’t seem to know what to do with tripped the whole thing up and it fell rather flat. Perhaps it was simply a case of first-night nerves, but the crucial pacing, which can make a good farce great, was lacking.

Christy set herself an ambitious task, aiming at once to “amuse while also delivering some poignant messages about the nature of love, privilege and common sense (or rather a distinct lack of)”. The breakneck speed of this play doesn’t allow much room for genre-switching moments of poignancy, and these missed their mark as often as they hit them. When it worked however, it really worked, as in Race’s excellent feminist economic theory speech, where the play verged into political satire. In other moments however, in trying to achieve both comedy and profundity, it didn’t quite reach either.

All told this was a welcome evening of genuinely funny comedy which left this audience member happy. The wonderful energy of individual performances, however, were not sustained across the whole, leaving a few jokes hanging and a few messages unabsorbed.

‘A Servant to Two Masters’ will be performed until Sat 28 Nov at the Senate Suite, Castle. Book your tickets here.

Photographs: Ana-Maria Cîrstea