A response to ‘The Financial Times: quotas do nothing for equality’
This piece is a response to an earlier article by Dominic Dixey.
Matilda Williams
Dominic Dixey recently reported on the FT’s new tool aimed at quoting more females, a move the newspaper hopes will increase the exposure of minority voices and encourage more women to read the paper. This article was, in my opinion, a misinformed and deeply upsetting piece I had no choice but to respond to.
The FT is not trying to discriminate against or undermine men; they are seeking to support female voices by quoting them more often. They do not want to quote exclusively women; they are attempting to arrive at a fair and equal balance. To deny the fairness of such actions is to deny that there is a plethora of educated, intelligent women who could offer as many insightful and useful quotes to the Financial Times as men. Dixey himself seems to admit this as he tells us that there are ‘plenty of women in public life’. If women are so equal, if institutionalised discrimination is a thing of the past, then why are women so underreported in the Financial Times? If our society is equal, would FT reporters not quote men and women equally anyway?
If women are so equal, if institutionalised discrimination is a thing of the past, then why are women so underreported in the Financial Times?
It seems contradictory to insist that women are equal in the financial or media workplace when there is clear inequality in the reporting of sexes in the FT. That inequality did not get there by itself; it is symptomatic of the underlying issues women face in the workplace. When Dixey insists that ‘being infrequently citied in their [FT] op-eds’ is not a high priority for women in financial media he is patronisingly assumptive about the value of a woman’s voice, and ignorant of the complex issues that prevent women from having such a voice. If more women can get heard, more women are listened to, and can gain more weight when impacting policy.
Dixey reminds us that we are now represented by a Queen and a female Prime Minister. But having a Queen is not synonymous with a gender-equal society, given that we have had them since medieval times, nor is the Queen a good example of a powerful woman, inheriting her largely ceremonial role. We may have a female Prime Minister, but globally only 6.3% of leaders are women. Only 32% of MPs are women; only 29% of FTSE 100 board members are women; only around 30% of people quoted in the FT are women; only 31% of the key editorial staff listed on their website are female. The Financial Conduit Authority puts the percentage of approved female traders at 13%, and finds some banks reporting gender pays gaps of 50%, and gaps of 80% in bonuses. 45% of journalists are female but they contribute just 25% front page by-lines.
These statistics do not mean there is discrimination in the workplace. They may correct themselves, in time, as more young women enter the workplace and older, more male-dominated generations age out. But it is not fair to expect women to rely on time as their only advocate for change. Men dominate our political and financial spheres, and therefore control them. This is how we end up with policies such as universal credit, which the New Statesman describes as a policy that ‘discriminates against women by design’, entrenching the idea that one person in a couple with children is a ‘main earner’ and another a ‘main carer’, discriminating against young mothers and single parents (90% of whom are women). It could be worth noting that the Work and Pensions Department is managed by five men and two women, that in 2016 women made up 69% of administrators in the lowest pay grades, while at the highest pay grade, Senior Civil Servants, 61% were male.
You cannot dominate a conversation 70% of the time while claiming the other person is getting an equal chance to speak.
You cannot dominate a conversation 70% of the time while claiming the other person is getting an equal chance to speak. Women are prevented from true equality by unfair policies, unfair cultural perceptions, and unfair cultural bias, such as the fact that women are consistently less likely to pass their driving test first time. Is this because they are neurotic wrecks who cannot deal with pressure, or is it because of the preconception that women are less capable drivers?
Yes, less men will have their voices and opinions heard. Yet this ignores the fact that women are already losing out on having their voices heard.
Dixey can insist that equality has been reached and there is nothing left to fight for, but I disagree. I must still fight against anybody who likens feminism to ‘soviet governance’, as should anybody who advocates for the rights and wellbeing of women. We need to fight against unfair policies, against institutional bias, which is itself a form of discrimination. The FT was not reporting enough women in its pages and has taken steps to address that. Yes, less men will have their voices and opinions heard. Yet this ignores the fact that women are already losing out on having their voices heard. We are underrepresented in the Financial Times – why is it such a bad thing that they are taking steps to address this?
Image by Gillian Tett (Financial Times) via Flickr
