A Reply – The European Union is Not Necessary for Years Abroad

By Ben Williams

Earlier this week, Luke Andrews submitted an article claiming that he believes Durham students voted in favour of Bremain as they were motivated by EU grant money for their years abroad.

Like many of you, I assumed that this was some form of satire, published by Palatinate to give us all a good laugh and relieve some exam stress. A witty pastiche of the suffering middle-class student, caught between their duty to the virtue of an independent Britain and the offer of cold, hard, European cash.

Unfortunately, it isn’t. So, given that Andrews managed to cut some time out of his busy schedule to write his article, I felt it only fair that I do the same and post a response.

First, he writes:

Most students reject the no camp on the basis that we need it for our Years Abroad. [But] I independently organised my own Year Abroad via the British Council and received absolutely no help from the EU.

As an anthropology student wanting to go to Spain to speak Spanish, my dream was declared impossible by my department. ‘You can go to the Netherlands, or the Czech Republic but nowhere else,’ they said, and certainly nowhere that doesn’t teach in English.

Not wishing to give up just yet, I consulted the languages department and was guided to the British Council programme. A chance to have a proper job as an English language assistant in Spain, earn money and learn Spanish. Perfect. 

I am glad that Andrews is having a great year abroad. I also am glad that he found enough “initiative” to channel his inner maverick and take on the Anthropology department before conquering the world.

Through all his self-congratulatory waffle though, he manages to make finding alternate sources of funding sound not just like an option but a practical one. From my own experience, I’m afraid, it’s not quite that simple.

I am not ashamed to say that I am one of very many students who needed that Erasmus money. In fact, I’ll happily break down my funding for the year: three months working in a UK call centre over the summer, a non-needs tested UK maintenance grant, part-time work alongside a full course load at a German university and, fundamentally, an Erasmus grant.

That’s right, I tried to fund it by myself, without help from family. And when you’re self-funding a year in a foreign country, 350 euros a month buys a great many pretzels.

Having wanted to keep studying rather than teaching, I didn’t qualify for the British Council scheme that helped Andrews fund his year. And neither did any of my friends who decided to complete internships or, if they showed enough “initiative”, found a job.

Quite simply, schemes like Andrews’ do exist, but they are not in a position to be able to cope with the sheer number of students nationally who complete years abroad. The Brexit campaign has, unsurprisingly, made no mention as to what sort of funding scheme it would set in place to aid students on this compulsory portion of their degrees. If Britain leaves the EU, Erasmus funding is gone.

But this is missing Andrews’ wider point. He ultimately concludes by saying that, because he was able to find a scheme, we shouldn’t be worried about not getting EU hand-outs any more. We are free to vote ‘leave’. The Empire will rule the waves once more. Yay.

I exaggerate, of course, but only slightly. Andrews’s writing isn’t too far off: “The worst the EU will do if we leave is slap on border controls. This means a bit more paper work, but if you really want to do a Year Abroad, you’ll do it.”

Once again though, this opinion isn’t only misguided, it is also inaccurate. Students aren’t, by and large, voting for Bremain because they want years abroad, or, if we follow Andrews’ logic, because we are desperate to get our miserly, money-grabbing hands on EU money.

In fact, only 2% percent of all students go on a year abroad each year (about 300 of all undergraduates), a figure which would still leave a decisive victory for the Bremain campaign in Durham if we assume a representative turnout. The DSU poll was decided by a 60% majority and statistics also show it would still have passed in every college.

More importantly still, I would also like to think that the vast majority of Durham students aren’t making this once-in-a-generation decision based on whether or not they might have to “fill out paperwork for a year abroad”.

Call me naïve, but I would have thought that an education costing us upwards of £27,000 might have taught us to think about some slightly bigger issues than a single source of student funding.

Maybe, for example, the Bremain voters are worried about the lack of debate around trade agreement models that an independent Britain might follow. Or they could be concerned about the impact of key businesses moving to mainland Europe on London house prices and job opportunities because that’s where most Durham students end up anyway. Perhaps some of us might even be thinking about what a movement based almost entirely on an anti-immigration rhetoric might say about Britain.

I am sure that you’re having a great time on your year abroad and I’m glad you found a way around the funding system consistent with your politics. I’m just not sure that you’ve solved the problem facing the Brexit campaign when it comes to student voters.

Photograph via Jean-Etienne Minh-Duy Poirrier