A place for debate? Kathleen Stock at the Oxford Union
By Siobhan Eddie
On Tuesday 30th May, Dr Kathleen Stock appeared at the Oxford Union. The polemical gender-critical feminist was invited to address the Union regarding her views on self-identification as a criterion for gender recognition and spoke about the protection of single-sex spaces. These very views were the ones that led to the anonymous campaign that forced Stock to resign from the University of Sussex in October 2021.
In the weeks leading up to Tuesday’s Union debate, Oxford University’s LGBTQ+ Society called upon the Union to rescind Stock’s invite, in a letter signed by 100 academics and staff. In response, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, amongst others, came out in support of Stock’s appearance, stating that her views on the topic should be heard and debated. The debate was accompanied by the sound of 200 trans-rights activists protesting outside the chamber in a “Trans+ Pride” demonstration, and was interrupted by trans-activist, Riz Posnet, gluing themself to the floor of the chamber near Stock’s feet.
No doubt, parallels can be drawn with events that occurred rather closer to home. In the same year as Stock’s resignation from the University of Sussex, Durham University’s South College became the focus of national attention. After Spectator and The Sunday Times columnist, Rod Liddle, was invited by the principal, Tim Luckhurst, to speak at the college’s Christmas Formal, students were left shocked and angry by Liddle’s claims. He spoke that “a person with an X and Y chromosome … is scientifically a man, and that is pretty much, scientifically, the end of the story”, and that “colonialism is not remotely the major cause of Africa’s problems”, both of which were made, Liddle then explained, to emphasise the importance of intellectual tolerance.
The similarities between Liddle and Stock’s appearances are clear, but it is the differences that are, in my view, more significant. While the debate surrounding gender identity is becoming increasingly emotive, and at times even toxic, what happened at the Oxford Union on Tuesday was evidence of healthy debate. There were, admittedly, a few protesters questioning why Stock had been given a platform to speak at all, following the LGBTQ+ Society’s call for the Union to “rescind its misguided invite”, but on the day itself, the demonstration’s organisers insisted that their aim was not to stop Stock from speaking, but rather to “celebrate trans+ joy, power, and lives”. Amiad Haran Diman, president of the LGBTQ+ Society and the leader of the march, stated that they would “make sure that the event [went] ahead”, because they “believe[d] in the rule of law”. Indeed, the actual disruption to the event was minimal, and Stock herself remarked that Posnett’s action was the kind of thing that she and her peers would have done while at university.
People like Liddle and Stock must be allowed to express their views, but no one should be forced to listen
The very fact that the LBGTQ+ Society was able to organise a peaceful “Trans+ Pride” protest exemplifies one of the key differences between Stock’s appearance at the Union, and Liddle’s speech at South College. Members of the Oxford community were given ample opportunity to prepare for Stock’s Union speech, and to think seriously about whether they wanted to attend.
By contrast, students at South College were not made aware beforehand of who would be speaking at the 2021 Christmas Formal, and thus, although at the time Luckhurst branded the student reaction as “pathetic”, the students can certainly be forgiven for feeling that they had almost been ambushed by Liddle’s after-dinner speech. People like Liddle and Stock must be allowed to express their views, but no one should be forced to listen, particularly on a topic as difficult and emotive as this.
Whether one agrees or disagrees with the strength of the student reaction to Liddle and Stock, it is not only the content of the discussion that matters here, but also its context. The Oxford Union, which will celebrate its bicentennial year in 2023, began as a “forum to uphold free speech” and to debate issues that could not be discussed in the university’s colleges. This is exactly the sort of place where people like Stock should appear. For someone whose views are so often misunderstood, Stock’s appearance is precisely what is needed to move past the toxic impasse that has been reached. It is unclear if we will ever emerge from this incensed stalemate, but, while the South College Christmas Formal was perhaps not the time or the place to try, the Oxford Union most certainly is.Â
Image credit: Michael D Beckwith via Wikimedia Commons
