A nuclear future: what are small modular reactors?

By Matthew Stow

The continuing advance of climate change and the ever-growing consumption of energy across the planet has made it apparent that our energy mix must transition away from fossil fuels towards cleaner alternatives. One such alternative, nuclear power, will see its “largest expansion in 70 years” according to the UK Department for Energy Security and Net Zero. 

In January, the department published the ‘2024 Civil Nuclear Roadmap to 2050’, detailing the long-term plans to increase the UK’s nuclear capacity by 270%. This will be achieved by retiring 4 of the 5 operational nuclear power stations in the coming decade, developing and deploying a new type of nuclear reactor called Small Modular Reactors (SMRs), alongside large power reactors like Hinkley point C and Sizewell C.

SMRs will generate electricity by the same conventional method that current nuclear power stations use, through fission of nuclear fuel.  In this process a heavy nucleus (typically Uranium) is made unstable by absorbing a neutron. The nucleus splits into two smaller nuclei, releasing energy and 2 to 3 neutrons in the process. The released neutrons form a chain reaction through absorption by surrounding nuclei, restarting the cycle, meanwhile, the energy released boils water, driving the turbines of a generator for electrical output.

About one tenth the size of existing nuclear power stations

Whilst the underlying principle may be the same, there are two key differences which separate SMRs from existing large power reactors. The first is their size. Rolls-Royce SMR, a company which specifically focuses on developing SMRs, state that their power stations will “occupy the footprint of two football pitches”, about one tenth the size of existing nuclear power stations. This decrease will come at the cost of a one third reduction in reactor power capacity.  The second key difference comes from the word ‘Modular’. Unlike large power reactors, which are custom designed to their site, SMRs will be manufactured in a single factory production line as prefabricated units to be assembled on site or fitted to repurposed fossil fuel power stations.

As a result of their modularity and size reduction, SMRs will be significantly cheaper to build than conventional nuclear power stations and have access to sites otherwise unsuitable for large power stations. Rolls Royce SMR states that each of their 470 MW SMR power stations will cost approximately £1.8 billion. Comparing this to Hinkley point C and Sizewell C which will cost an estimated £35 billion and £20 billion respectively, it is clear SMRs will provide more cost-efficient power.

As with existing nuclear power stations, SMRs will likely face opposition from members of the public for fear of repeating disasters like Chernobyl or Fukushima. In spring 2024 the Office of National Statistics reported that 41% of people would oppose the construction of a nuclear power plant in their local area, with 80% of these people stating concerns regarding the safety of the power station. A mere 21% were in support of a local nuclear power plant. These safety concerns, however, appear unfounded.

When comparing the death rate per unit of electricity production, nuclear power is estimated to cause 0.03 deaths per terawatt hour, meanwhile the rates for coal, oil and gas are 24.6, 18.4 and 2.82 respectively.  More generally, the energy consumption of 150,000 average Europeans across 33 years would result in only 1 premature death from nuclear power compared to a combined 1518 deaths from fossil fuels. Furthermore, SMRs will likely serve to increase the safety of nuclear power as their designs rely on passive systems and inherent safety characteristics, that don’t require external power or human intervention, such as natural convection, gravity and self-pressurisation.

The next generation of nuclear power in the form of SMRs will play an important role in the green transition

 In terms of management of radioactive waste, SMRs will have an extended fuel cycle, with reactors needing refuelling every 3 to 7 years, compared to 1 to 2 years for conventional plants. Even with an increased fuel cycle, spent nuclear fuel will remain a problem for the UK. As of November 2018, the UK stopped reprocessing spent nuclear fuel from its 14 Advanced Gas Reactors. Ever since, temporary storage measures have been taken with radioactive waste from these reactors stored at Sellafield and spent fuel from Sizewell B remaining on site. The Nuclear Waste Services has outlined the long-term solution of a geological disposal facility, which will contain waste for hundreds of years, to be operational for intermediate waste between 2050 and 2060, and high-level in 2075.

As with all nuclear reactors, SMRs will enter the decommissioning phase in the final stage of their lives.  Decommissioning involves defueling and disassembly of a nuclear reactor and its power plant to return the site to a reusable state.  According to the International Atomic Energy Agency, this has proven to be expensive for early generations of nuclear power plants as they were “designed with decommissioning as an afterthought”; in contrast SMRs will be “designed with disposal in mind”.  SMRs will utilise their modularity to transport entire reactors back to decommissioning facilities, increasing efficiency and reducing the daily dose rate of workers during the process.

Projections from the Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy predict that the UK’s energy demand may increase by up to 110% by 2050. Whilst renewable energy sources like solar and hydroelectric power will be vital in compensating for this increase, there is no denying that with their reduced size, cost efficiency and enhanced safety, the next generation of nuclear power in the form of SMRs will play an important role in the green transition.

Image: Stefan Kuhn via Wikimedia Commons