A lack of training results in repeated failings of JCR finances
Whilst the topic of JCR finances is arguably not the most riveting, it was deemed worthy of a front page article, one which I feel so strongly about that I am sitting at my computer bashing out a response to it. The gist of the article was that JCRs themselves are entirely responsible for the mess that some of them are in; yet, as a JCR treasurer (not of one of the infamous four, I am pleased to declare) I can say from personal experience that colleges and the University must be blamed to a large extent for problems with JCR finances.
As far as I am concerned, it is apathy on their part that has contributed to long-term problems. When a student is elected to deal with a large turnover for one year, surely the University or the college should ensure that the student is sufficiently trained and not just let loose with all that cash? You would think so, but no. This does not seem to be the case in any college in Durham.
My college has never shown any interest in checking that I am comfortable with what I am supposed to be doing. I have presented accounts to two meetings of College Council and, on both occasions, the questioning was light. It is conceivable that I could have completely made up all the figures (best to be reassuring – I did not do so). All I am doing is what my predecessor told me to do and, as the article pointed out, bad habits could get passed down.
It took the fuss over the Charities Act to make the University aware that full-time students with no support might struggle to keep adequate records, complete VAT returns and everything else that is involved with managing a large turnover. Durham’s Business Assurance Service – the role of which includes “compliance checking of core financial and transactional systems” – was tasked with auditing JCR accounts for 2008 in light of the need to register as charities, and they discovered that bad habits did indeed get passed down from treasurer to treasurer: running more bank accounts than necessary, not keeping accurate records and so on.
In response, John Ashworth, Deputy Warden, called a meeting for all JCR treasurers and treasurers-elect towards the end of Epiphany term where, after a thorough telling-off, he told us that not all was lost, that he was there to put us on the right track and that he would ensure that we were properly trained. Aside from suggesting that those JCRs who do not use Microsoft Excel should do so, this meeting was not useful and did not explain how we could rectify the problems we were facing.
Easter term came and I began my year as treasurer without any word from the University. I had a few handover sessions with my predecessor and set about the job as she had. Within the last fortnight of term, Business Assurance contacted treasurers to invite them to attend an optional guidance session lasting approximately thirty minutes. I was unable to attend but was promised a list of general pointers. They never came.
In July, I had to submit my first VAT return. For those who do not know, this is pretty major – failure to submit at all or submitting an incorrect return could result in a massive fine for the JCR. Had training been provided? Given my tone thus far, I do not think I need to answer that question. Such vital training was left until a few days before the deadline for submission of my (and other treasurers’) second VAT returns at the end of October. This occurred at the end of another meeting called by John Ashworth, where the content was pretty identical to that of the Epiphany term meeting: promises of help to put things right but no practical support.
Treasurers Committee, an opportunity for treasurers to sit down together to share issues and ideas, which was first suggested by John Ashworth in the first meeting with him, got off the ground a few weeks later, thanks to the DSU President. In my eyes, this committee is typical of the University’s ‘help yourselves because we are not going to’ attitude.
On February 2nd this year, Business Assurance sent the Chair of Treasurers Committee a memorandum to be sent to all JCR treasurers. This memo requested complete 2009 accounts to be submitted by February 15th or else special measures would be implemented. An extremely short deadline and a threat in the same memo!
A member of Business Assurance visited a meeting of Treasurers Committee the following day, and revealed that the deadline had been “agreed with John Ashworth” a while before. We treasurers had not been immediately informed of the deadline and had not been consulted on a suitable deadline. Yet I recall John Ashworth in the Epiphany 2009 meeting saying he would work with treasurers to determine a suitable deadline for submission of accounts. I am flabbergasted that after not attempting to train treasurers properly and thereby allowing things to go from the proverbial bad to worse, the University, despite now acknowledging that treasurers need help, is not forthcoming with it and continues to heap pressure upon us.
Anyway, I have spent far too much time writing this. I had better crack on with finishing the 2009 accounts now…
