A game of two halves: Lewis Hamilton is the right choice for Ferrari

By Amelia Clayton and Oliver Spark

In a new feature included in every print edition, two writers take part in a head-to-head debate surrounding a key issue in the world of sport. This week, we asked Sport Contributors Amelia Clayton and Oliver Spark whether they agreed or disagreed with the statement: Lewis Hamilton is the right choice for Ferrari

Yes (Amelia Clayton):

It’s no secret that this season has been challenging for Lewis Hamilton. With three races to go, Hamilton’s teammate George Russell has out-qualified him on 16 occasions and is beating him 11-6 in races (DNFs and disqualifications excluded). Hamilton’s Ferrari contract was signed before the start of the current season, a demonstration of their faith in him, but should his recent performances be a concern for Ferrari?

Since 2022, Hamilton has struggled adapting to the new regulations. Mercedes’ engineering director Andrew Shovlin has suggested that this is partly because Hamilton’s way of attacking corners (late braking and sharp turns) creates oversteer in the modern cars. His more offensive style makes it difficult to generate tyre temperature, a challenge also noted by Fernando Alonso, a driver who shares Hamilton’s older style. Both drivers have encountered various issues in qualifying due to this. While Ferrari may not be able to help Hamilton with this next season, he will remain under contract with the team for 2026 when the next regulation change could shift conditions in his favour.

Even at 39 years old, the seven-time world champion is not a name that any top team would reject

Despite this season’s challenges, Hamilton has still managed two wins, delivering impressive performances in Belgium and Great Britain. Although Russell beat him to the finish line at Spa, Hamilton’s inherited win following Russell’s disqualification reflected a strong drive. When track conditions have favoured the Mercedes, Hamilton has been there to capitalise, demonstrating that when he has the car to perform he is still one of the best drivers on the grid.

Hamilton has struggled against a talented young teammate this season, and Leclerc will not be any less of a challenge. However, Sainz is currently 63 points off Leclerc, while Hamilton is only two points away from his equally competitive teammate. Though Hamilton may no longer be in his prime, he remains a formidable presence. He may not beat Leclerc, but he won’t be far behind.

Carlos Sainz has been impressive for Ferrari, earning two grand prix wins this season. However, he is not Lewis Hamilton. Even at 39 years old, the seven-time world champion is not a name that any top team would reject.

No (Oliver Spark):

Hamilton to Ferrari was the most romantic matchup that could have happened in Formula 1. Better still, it eclipsed Helmut Marko’s controversial comments with something of note. However, in the months after, the talk of Hamilton diminished, and focus turned to incumbent Ferrari driver Carlos Sainz.

Sainz was dropped from Ferrari like Andy dropped Woody in Toy Story, but rather than scrambling to find a drive, Sainz’ stock has proved to be astronomical. After a huge offer from Audi, and interest from Mercedes and Alpine, it is Williams who have put their faith in him. They believe Sainz can walk into their team and, as he has shown at Ferrari, be the perfect team player.  

There is a disconnect between the romance of a home-grown talent winning, and a seven-time world champion finishing his career on a high

Strangely enough, the head-to-heads of the two drivers this season are similar. Hamilton has only outperformed his teammate twice more than Sainz, begging the question (in performance terms at least) why Ferrari have swapped out a well-regarded, team-focused driver for a seven-time world champion hell-bent on securing an eighth. During the 2022 season, Sainz proved to be the perfect second driver to compliment a title chasing Leclerc – the same cannot be said for Hamilton, especially after his famous rivalry with Rosberg in the mid-2010s. This must be a concern for Ferrari if they believe they can challenge for the title next season

Moreover, Ferrari have arguably not had a talent like Leclerc since the Schumacher days. The Tifosi love him, and through their six-year relationship the narrative has been absolute commitment to winning together. It must be a shock to Leclerc that ‘his’ team have brought a guaranteed winner in an attempt to maximise their chances. There is a disconnect between the romance of a home-grown talent winning, and a seven-time world champion finishing his career on a high. Ferrari have a situation where one driver and their huge following must miss out, and the consequences could be sizeable.

The team must hope they have committed to a harmonious driver line up that delivers sensational wins, with both drivers supporting each other to the title if the car (and Hamilton) allows.

Alberto-g-rovi via Wikimedia Commons